McRitchie Studio

Scout report: request-changes - Primary review: preview fixture renders the Evolve card, but current PR head 29f46ea2 is not merge-ready because GitHub CI test is red. Reporter: shannon Outcome: request-changes Findings: - BLOCKER: GitHub CI test job fails on current head 29f46ea2; test/system/task_timeline_mascot_history_test.rb:70 still expects Charizard as a normal timeline crew member after this PR moves that face into the Evolve reel. - NON-BLOCKER: PR is mergeable against release and preview URL returned 200 with assembled Steffon-only plus Evolve reel markers present. Questions: - none Checks: - Read /Users/alex/projects/AGENTS.md, Avi pr-review SOP, modular PR review SOP, README, RUNBOOK, ECOSYSTEM, frontend/testing docs. - Inspected PR metadata/body/comments/diff/changed files; no PR comments; base release; changed helper, timeline partial, and three test files. - GitHub checks on 29f46ea2: scan_ruby pass, scan_js pass, lint pass, test fail. - Local PR-head checks: bin/rails test test/system/task_timeline_mascot_history_test.rb:44 reproduced 1 failure; PR-added helper/view/integration tests passed 83 runs, 360 assertions. - DoR command still reports green from stale recorded full-suite SHA 18415b5492fa, so current head CI overrides it.

pr-review blocked review: shannon: request-changes - current PR head 29f46ea2 is not merge-ready because GitHub CI test is red; test/system/task_timeline_mascot_history_test.rb:70 still expects Charizard as a normal timeline crew member after this PR moves that face into the Evolve reel.

Resolved shannon's request-changes (red CI system lane). Root cause: test/system/task_timeline_mascot_history_test.rb:70 still asserted Charizard as a plain timeline-crew-member, but this branch lifts the third-stage form into its own Evolve reel. Fix (commit e1d65363): assert Charizard in the reel (timeline-evolution-to) + assert_no_selector for a Charizard crew member. My earlier full-suite-check only ran 'bin/rails test' (regular lane) which excludes test/system — CI runs 'test test:system'. Re-certified CI-faithfully with FULL_SUITE_TEST_CMD='bin/rails test && bin/rails test:system': both lanes + rubocop green at c041c12b8110; system lane 8 runs/0 failures. dor-check ✓. PR #391 updated.

Scout report: request-changes - Request changes: happy path and CI are green, but third_evolution false-positives on skipped submit gate. Reporter: jasper Outcome: request-changes Findings: - BLOCKER app/helpers/stage_agents_helper.rb:441 treats any assembled snapshot change as an Evolve moment. The supported direct building->assembled path evolves only Charmander->Charmeleon, yet the helper renders an Evolve card, violating the only-third-stage acceptance criterion. Questions: - none Checks: - GitHub PR #391 targets release, is open/non-draft, mergeStateStatus CLEAN, and CI scan_ruby/scan_js/lint/test all succeeded at e1d6536378779b18334b23cedc1f30471e266c29. - Inspected task metadata, PR body, changed helper/view/tests, and open PR overlap; #395 also touches _consolidated_timeline.html.erb but #391 is clean against current release. - Reproduced locally in the feature worktree with RAILS_ENV=test mise exec ruby@3.3.11 -- bin/rails runner: direct assemble probe returned third_evolution [charmander,charmeleon] and block_stages included evolve.

Scout report: merge-ready - No blockers found. PR #391 matches the third-evolution timeline and board acceptance criteria and is clean to merge into release. Reporter: shannon Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - Acceptance matched: Reviewed->Assembled renders Steffon alone, the synthetic Evolve card shows the before->after reel credited to Steffon, shipped renders Avi alone, and the deployments card stacks the evolved form on the build crew. - Merge safety is acceptable: PR targets release, GitHub reports MERGEABLE/CLEAN, origin/release is the merge base, and the only same-file open-PR overlap found is PR #395's adjacent Review Events label change. - Non-blocking edge noted: a manually skipped building->assembled transition can produce a first-step mascot diff, but the documented release path reaches assembled from reviewed and the normal/2-stage acceptance paths are covered. Questions: - none Checks: - Inspected AGENTS.md, README.md, ECOSYSTEM.md, Avi pr-review SOP, shared pr-review-sop, task-board docs, task metadata, PR body, diff, changed files, CI, and open PR overlap. - GitHub CI for PR #391 is green: lint, test, scan_js, and scan_ruby passed at e1d6536378779b18334b23cedc1f30471e266c29; gh reports mergeStateStatus CLEAN. - Local targeted verification on the PR worktree passed: bin/rails test test/helpers/stage_agents_helper_test.rb test/views/consolidated_timeline_test.rb test/integration/board_card_stage_avatars_test.rb -> 83 runs, 360 assertions, 0 failures. - Local browser/system verification passed: bin/rails test test/system/task_timeline_mascot_history_test.rb -> 3 runs, 10 assertions, 0 failures; local URL returned 200 and parsed DOM matched the Evolve/crew placement.

pr-review blocked review: shannon: merge-ready - No blockers found. PR #391 matches the third-evolution timeline and board acceptance criteria and is clean to merge into release.; jasper: request-changes - Request changes: happy path and CI are green, but third_evolution false-positives on skipped submit gate.

Resolved jasper's request-changes (third_evolution false-positive on skipped submit gate). Fix (commit b4440ddf): third_evolution now requires the form ENTERING the assemble gate to be a NON-base form — proof the mascot already evolved once at the submit gate. So a task that reaches assembled WITHOUT the submit gate (its FIRST evolution, Charmander → Charmeleon, happening AT assemble) no longer renders a bogus Evolve card. Added a skipped-submit regression test (stage_agents_helper_test) + seeded the evolution line in the timeline/board fixtures so the base-form guard resolves. Re-certified BOTH lanes CI-faithfully (bin/rails test && bin/rails test:system) on a fresh DB: 2811 + 8 runs, 0 failures; rubocop clean; certified 3d0b3f1f1e43. dor-check ✓. shannon already marked merge-ready.

Scout report: merge-ready - No blockers. Current head b4440ddf resolves the skipped-submit false-positive, matches the third-evolution timeline/board acceptance criteria, and is green on focused local tests plus latest GitHub CI. Reporter: jasper Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - No blockers: third_evolution now requires the form entering the assemble gate to be non-base, so the prior building->assembled first-evolution false-positive is covered by regression test. - Acceptance matched: Reviewed->Assembled renders Steffon alone, the Evolve card shows the before->after reel credited to Steffon, shipped renders Avi alone, and the board stacks the evolved form on the build crew. - Non-blocker: open draft PR #395 also touches _consolidated_timeline.html.erb, but PR #391 is mergeable and merge-tree against current origin/release is clean. Questions: - none Checks: - Read AGENTS.md, README, ECOSYSTEM, Avi pr-review SOP, shared pr-review SOP, DevOps task-board docs, and testing docs; inspected task metadata, PR body, diff, changed files, scout history, CI, and open PR overlap. - GitHub PR #391 at b4440ddf: scan_ruby, scan_js, lint, and test all SUCCESS; gh reports MERGEABLE. - Focused local verification with Homebrew Ruby PATH passed: bin/rails test test/helpers/stage_agents_helper_test.rb test/integration/board_card_stage_avatars_test.rb test/views/consolidated_timeline_test.rb test/system/task_timeline_mascot_history_test.rb => 87 runs, 371 assertions, 0 failures. - Local URL http://localhost:3004/tasks/evolve-demo-charmander-line returned 200; rendered HTML includes assembled Steffon-only card plus Evolve reel markers for Charmeleon->Charizard triggered by Steffon.

Scout report: merge-ready - PR #391 at b4440ddf matches the third-evolution acceptance criteria after the skipped-submit regression fix; CI, DoR, focused local tests, and merge safety are green. Reporter: shannon Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - No blockers: third_evolution now requires the assembled snapshot to change from a non-base entering form, preventing the skipped-submit first-evolution false positive. - Timeline renders the Evolve reel as Charmeleon to Charizard with Steffon trigger, while assembled and shipped deploy cards are soul-only. - Deployments board stacks the evolved third form on the build crew and leaves deploy clusters soul-only; same-file draft overlap with PR #395 pairwise merge-trees cleanly. Questions: - none Checks: - Reviewed task metadata, PR body, commits, changed files, prior feedback, and open PR overlap. - GitHub CI green: lint, scan_js, scan_ruby, and test. - Local focused suite green with Homebrew Ruby PATH: 87 runs, 371 assertions, 0 failures. - bin/dor-check surface-third-evolution-moment passed; git merge-tree origin/release origin/pr-391 produced a clean tree.

pr-review moved surface-third-evolution-moment to reviewed after shannon + jasper reported merge-ready. Left for Steffon QA. Reports: - shannon: merge-ready - PR #391 at b4440ddf matches the third-evolution acceptance criteria after the skipped-submit regression fix; CI, DoR, focused local tests, and merge safety are green. - jasper: merge-ready - No blockers. Current head b4440ddf resolves the skipped-submit false-positive, matches the third-evolution timeline/board acceptance criteria, and is green on focused local tests plus latest GitHub CI.