McRitchie Studio

Scout report: merge-ready - Light second read clean: session-scoped streams exactly mirror the HTTP filter (only filter dimension is sessions, exact-match where(session_id:)); subscriptions live inside aa-activities-frame so filter navigation swaps them; unfiltered path keeps global stream with identical actions/targets; broadcast errors surface via Studio::Cable.safe_broadcast -> ErrorLog. Reporter: jasper Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - Non-blocker: stream_for_session strips stored session_id while HTTP filter matches the raw stored value - a whitespace-padded stored id would live-append to a filtered page that excludes it in render; pathological since ids are machine-generated. - Non-blocker: every activity/action after_commit now renders+publishes 2x (global + session stream) even with no session subscriber - fine today, watch if capture volume grows. - Note: checks_run carries [full-suite-bypass] (SIGTERM 143 under concurrent load) - primary owns that gate call; PR CI test job is green (05:54Z) which corroborates the same-diff green claim. Questions: - none Checks: - diff read vs origin/release (single commit 909b9485, cleanly rebased on bc38e331) - controller filter predicate vs broadcast stream scoping mirrored - subscription lifecycle inside turbo-frame verified in view + integration test

Scout report: merge-ready - Re-review confirms fix: stream sources render INSIDE turbo-frame#aa-activities-frame via new _activities_live_streams partial; old outside-frame turbo_stream_from removed; in-frame filter nav now swaps subscriptions correctly. Regression coverage is genuine: frame-scoped assert_select turbo-frame#aa-activities-frame turbo-cable-stream-source plus filtered-page refute of the global signed stream name. All 4 CI lanes green. Reporter: jasper Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - Placement fix verified: partial renders as first child inside the frame, so filter/Clear-all frame swaps disconnect stale sources and connect scoped ones - Broadcaster fans out to global + session-scoped streams; pages subscribe to exactly one scope (never both) so no duplicate inserts - Controller parse_session_ids and streams_for_filters normalize identically (strip/reject-blank/uniq); blank session_id activities safely hit global only - Non-blocker: session-filtered broadcasts render each partial twice (global + session stream) — acceptable fan-out cost for this feed Questions: - none Checks: - gh pr view 452: OPEN, not draft, base release, CI scan_ruby/scan_js/lint/test all SUCCESS - branch merge-base equals current origin/release tip bc38e331 — zero release drift

Scout report: merge-ready - Light read clean: protocol/controller/view/tests match all acceptance bullets; admin-gated via proven require_admin pattern; no constantize of user input; registry ships empty. One acceptance bullet (consumer CI green) unmet AS-WRITTEN: mcritchie lane red on AgentWorktreeTest repo-layout env coupling in mcritchie's own suite, unrelated to this diff; turf lane green. Needs job re-run or mcritchie-side harness fix, not PR rework. Reporter: jasper Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - mcritchie consumer CI failure = AgentWorktreeTest#test_mcritchie_config_reserves_3020 aborting 'repo missing' on runner layout; test lives in mcritchie-studio, known-flaky lane, diff touches no workflow/harness — environmental, supervisor's call to re-run or waive - non-blocker: ModelPage#json uses record.as_json which ignores filter_attributes and DECRYPTS encrypts-declared attrs — document 'never register secret-bearing models' or filter via model.filter_attributes before any app registers wallet-like models - non-blocker: registration in a plain initializer holds live class refs; Zeitwerk dev reload leaves stale classes — recommend documenting to_prepare registration - non-blocker: /models/:model/:id has no :id constraint; dotted identifiers split as format — add id: /[^\/]+/ if dotted slugs ever registered Questions: - none Checks: - gh pr view #12: OPEN, not draft, base release, mergeable - Consumer CI: turf_monster SUCCESS, mcritchie_studio FAILURE (env coupling, evidence in report) - route-order test asserts random drawn before :id catch-all

Scout report: merge-ready - Light second read clean: broadcaster fans out global+session streams; filtered pages subscribe session-scoped only. All 3 acceptance criteria mechanically satisfied and test-covered. CI green on PR head. Reporter: jasper Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - Non-blocker: PR is still a draft; fix is gh pr ready at the submit seam - Non-blocker: deliver_action_created/updated now load the full agent_activity record (one extra query per action broadcast) instead of the id; needed for session routing Questions: - none Checks: - gh pr view 452: OPEN, base release, MERGEABLE, CI scan_ruby/scan_js/lint/test all SUCCESS - branch contains current origin/release (merge-base ancestor check); no other agents_activities subscribers on release

Scout report: merge-ready - Light review (blockchain/library lens): admin-gating, registry-constantize, JSON-exposure, route-order all sound. No blockers. Reporter: jasper Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - require_admin correctly applied and fails closed: Studio::ModelsController mirrors existing Studio::EmailImagesController pattern; require_admin (error_handling.rb:163) redirects non-admins/guests; runs BEFORE load_page so no model-existence oracle. - No constantize: ModelPage.new resolves params[:model] via registry.fetch{raise UnknownModel}->404; only host-registered live class refs reachable. Empty-registry claim holds. - No stored-XSS: view renders <%= @page.json %> in .html.erb (auto-escaped); copy_button escapes text/data-attr; admin-only surface. - Route order correct: models/:model/random drawn before models/:model/:id with a dedicated regression test. - NON-BLOCKER: record.as_json dumps ALL columns (no only:/except: hook) - fine for admin+opt-in v1, but a sensitive registered model exposes everything; consider attribute-filter in Entry later. - NON-BLOCKER: order(RANDOM()).first is a full-table sort - acceptable for low-volume admin debug, perf smell on large tables. - NIT: version.rb bumped to 0.12.0 but CHANGELOG entry still under '## Unreleased' (Keep-a-Changelog would cut to '0.12.0 - date' on gem release). Questions: - none Checks: - mcritchie consumer CI RED on env-brittle AgentWorktreeTest (unrelated to this diff) - Carl/primary owns that gate call; turf CI green.

Scout report: merge-ready - Light read: tight ui-only recency polish; description matches diff, no unrelated churn, well-covered across helper/component/integration tiers. Two nits, no blockers. Reporter: jasper Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - NIT: compact_time_ago renders '0m ago' for the 45-59s window (just-now cutoff 45s vs minute floor 60s); bumping the just-now threshold to 60s closes it. - NIT: helper comment and PR blurb say '(s/m/h/d/w)' but no seconds unit is ever emitted — smallest output is 'just now'. Questions: - none Checks: - Verified activity_feed.rb builds last_at as the MAX-merge union of AgentAction.occurred_at and AgentActivity.opened_at (union sort intact; activity-only sessions retained). - Integration test hits real path and asserts '2m ago' renders + newest-first order — confirms session[:last_at] is populated in production, label is not dead.

Scout report: merge-ready - Light UI second read found the condensed current-release member summary aligned with acceptance; GitHub CI is green at PR head and merge/file-overlap safety is clean. Reporter: jasper Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - No blockers. - Non-blocker: task/PR local full-suite and RuboCop stamps reference cf5dadb1 rather than current head 21afea8b, but GitHub test/lint/scans succeeded at 21afea8b. Questions: - Only if product requires strict two-item condensation for every 3+ member release: this helper intentionally leaves three unsized/no-cost tasks visible as fixed highlight pills. Checks: - Read AGENTS, pr-review-light SOP, README, ecosystem/frontend/testing/deployment/data-model docs; inspected task metadata, PR body, final diff, helper/view/tests, CI, open PR file overlap, worktree status, and local /up.

Scout report: merge-ready - Light UI/release-dashboard read found no blockers; condensed current release members match acceptance and CI is green. Reporter: jasper Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - Blockers: none found in helper, partial, tests, PR body, task metadata, or rendered /deployments markup. - Non-blocker: PR is still draft and overlaps same files with open PRs #438 and #434; GitHub currently reports CLEAN against release. Questions: - none Checks: - Read AGENTS.md, README, ECOSYSTEM, Avi pr-review-light SOP, Jasper role checklist, task metadata, PR body, diff, and changed files. - Verified reported checks via gh pr checks: lint, scan_js, scan_ruby, and test all pass; did not rerun gates. - Local URL http://localhost:3019/deployments returned 200 with two highlighted task links, two cost badges, fade-mask title spans, and repo-count summaries.

Scout report: merge-ready - No code blockers in light UI read: lead avatar scales on its own wrapper, stack spacing stays fixed, and 3/4-slot alignment coverage matches acceptance. Current PR is clean against release with CI green at a801c88. Reporter: jasper Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - Blockers: none found. - Non-blocker merge safety: open PR #441 also edits app/views/components/_stage_agent_avatars.html.erb; git merge-tree reports a conflict if both branches merge without sequencing or rebase. - Non-blocker process: task-recorded full-suite/rubocop hash cbae5ad8eeb1598cf8eb5cba4e466c71fd7ebed1 is a tree/no GitHub commit, but GitHub CI test/lint are green on head a801c88. Questions: - none Checks: - Read AGENTS.md, pr-review-light SOP, README, frontend/deployment/testing docs, and Jasper role. - Inspected task metadata, PR body, changed files, diff, CI statusCheckRollup, and open-PR file overlap. - Compared origin/release...origin/pr-443; only avatar partial and component integration test changed, with no on-chain surface. - Did not rerun gates per light reviewer SOP.

Scout report: merge-ready - Light review found no blockers; shiny badge polish matches acceptance and keeps sprite behavior intact. Reporter: jasper Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - No blocker: avatar badge now renders as a large raw sparkle without bg/border/rounded/shadow classes. - No blocker: stacked crew render forces under-stack shiny badges off while leaving the visible lead badge eligible. - Non-blocker merge safety: PR #443 also edits _stage_agent_avatars; read-only merge-tree shows a conflict, so #443 should preserve this PR's shiny: false-under-stack arg when rebased or assembled. Questions: - none Checks: - PR #441 is open against release, non-draft, mergeable clean, and GitHub CI scan_ruby/scan_js/lint/test are successful. - Task metadata acceptance/checks match the PR body; reported full-suite/rubocop tree hash matches HEAD tree 12d5598a. - Diff read against origin/release: 4 files, no whitespace errors; no on-chain/Jasper checklist surface touched.

Scout report: request-changes - Light review found highlight selection ranks by size, not measured cost, so the release card can omit the true highest-cost tasks. Reporter: jasper Outcome: request-changes Findings: - Blocker: release_member_highlights sorts by release_member_expense_weight from size fields only; measured task.total_cost is used for badges but ignored for selection. Questions: - none Checks: - Read AGENTS, light SOP, Jasper role, README/data model/routes/deployment docs; inspected task metadata, PR body, diff/tests/CI, merge-tree; local /up 200 and deployments HTML shows condensed markup.

Scout report: merge-ready - Light review: all 3 acceptance criteria met; coupled-pair #431 verbs resolve; 2 non-blocking nits Reporter: jasper Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - AC1-3 met: result-distillation.md documents policy, validate->resolve->finding shape, two nested grains (action finding + activity verdict) - Coupled-pair OK: bin/agent-activity loads atomic-event so 'action --summary' resolves to the verb #431 extends; #431 drop rule (tool-results/ dir Reads dropped, all else kept) matches doc's suppression claim - NIT: doc illustration 'reopening a file to see the next chunk' is broader than #431 (only drops spilled tool-results/ reads, keeps real-file chunk-paging) - NIT: doc examples omit --finding, so recorded findings land kind=bash not #431's queryable 'finding' verb Questions: - none Checks: - gh pr diff 430/431 read-only; referenced atomic-capture-hook.md exists; index link convention matches siblings

Scout report: conductor-review - Randomized glow motion meets its UI acceptance, but shared PR #415 is draft and includes blocked sibling tasks, so Avi should reconcile PR readiness before review advances. Reporter: jasper Outcome: conductor-review Findings: - No code blockers for randomized motion: task cards derive deterministic per-card --studio-border-glow-offset, duration, and angle variables from task.slug, while CSS animates only background-position on absolute pseudo-elements. - Reduced motion remains covered at the primitive level by setting animation: none on .studio-border-glow::before and ::after; submitted cards also keep --studio-border-glow-animation: none. - Merge/admin gate: PR #415 isDraft=true and the same PR includes blocked sibling tasks deployment-rainbow-border, deployment-border-variants, and pokemon-assembled-glow, so this task should not be treated as independently merge-ready. - Merge safety otherwise looks clean: GitHub reports mergeStateStatus CLEAN, git merge-tree HEAD origin/release returned a clean tree, and other open release PRs do not touch this deployment-card CSS/partial/test file set. Questions: - none Checks: - [component] bin/rails test test/views/task_card_test.rb test/views/deployments_live_fx_test.rb passed: 19 runs, 273 assertions. - [integration] live smoke at http://localhost:3004/deployments found 5 task glow cards with varied offsets, durations, and angles; /up returned 200. - [dor] bin/dor-check randomized-glow-motion passed with component tier, full-suite/rubocop certificate, and 4 green GitHub CI checks. - [ci] gh pr checks 415 reports scan_ruby, scan_js, lint, and test all pass at PR head d2c0ccc.

Scout report: merge-ready - Light review: acceptance matched, no blockers; CI and focused local checks green, PR mergeable into release. Reporter: jasper Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - Blockers: none. - Non-blocker: prefers-reduced-motion slows assembled/confirming border animation to 42s rather than disabling it; acceptable for this glow-focused PR. - Questions: none. Questions: - none Checks: - PR metadata: base release, head feat/submitted-blocked-glow, mergeable; no unresolved review threads. - CI: gh pr checks 398 all pass (scan_ruby, scan_js, lint, test). - Local focused: Homebrew Ruby PATH prefix + bin/rails test task_card/deployments_live_fx/tasks_controller/deployments_broadcaster -> 125 runs, 781 assertions, 0 failures. - Asset/local: bin/rails tailwindcss:build succeeded; curl /up and /deployments on localhost:3010 returned 200; HTML contains stage glow classes.

Scout report: merge-ready - Light review found no blockers; PR #399 is open, clean against release, and dor-check now gates merge on real GitHub CI while leaving build gate untouched. Reporter: jasper Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - No blockers in the changed gate code: CiStatus feeds only the merge gate; red/pending/closed/merged states block, green passes, and gh/no-checks degrade to non-blocking suggestions. - Open PR #361 overlaps bin/dor-check, test/lib/dor_check_test.rb, and the DevOps design doc, but an isolated merge rehearsal of #399 then #361 auto-merged cleanly. - Non-blocking wording note: the task text says no-PR should be noted unverifiable, while this PR intentionally keeps a missing pr_url silent; no-checks and gh-error paths still show UNVERIFIED suggestions. Questions: - none Checks: - ruby -Itest test/lib/ci_status_test.rb: 10 runs, 25 assertions, green. - ruby -Itest test/lib/dor_check_test.rb: 87 runs, 557 assertions, green. - bin/dor-check gate-dor-check-on-github-ci: ready, full-suite fingerprint 5aeefabec18d, GitHub CI green (4 checks). - gh PR metadata: #399 is OPEN, base release, mergeState CLEAN, head 8fb95a73, four CI checks passing.

Scout report: merge-ready - Light review: CI gate implementation matches acceptance; live PR CI is green and dor-check is ready. Reporter: jasper Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - No blockers. Overlaps PR #361 in bin/dor-check, docs/agents/system/devops-cycle-design.md, and test/lib/dor_check_test.rb, but pairwise git merge-tree is clean and the combined tree preserves both gate changes. Questions: - none Checks: - ruby -Itest test/lib/ci_status_test.rb; ruby -Itest test/lib/dor_check_test.rb; bin/dor-check gate-dor-check-on-github-ci --json; gh pr checks 399; git merge-tree --write-tree --quiet origin/feat/harden-the-devops-gate origin/feat/gate-dor-check-on-github-ci

Scout report: merge-ready - No blockers. Current head b4440ddf resolves the skipped-submit false-positive, matches the third-evolution timeline/board acceptance criteria, and is green on focused local tests plus latest GitHub CI. Reporter: jasper Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - No blockers: third_evolution now requires the form entering the assemble gate to be non-base, so the prior building->assembled first-evolution false-positive is covered by regression test. - Acceptance matched: Reviewed->Assembled renders Steffon alone, the Evolve card shows the before->after reel credited to Steffon, shipped renders Avi alone, and the board stacks the evolved form on the build crew. - Non-blocker: open draft PR #395 also touches _consolidated_timeline.html.erb, but PR #391 is mergeable and merge-tree against current origin/release is clean. Questions: - none Checks: - Read AGENTS.md, README, ECOSYSTEM, Avi pr-review SOP, shared pr-review SOP, DevOps task-board docs, and testing docs; inspected task metadata, PR body, diff, changed files, scout history, CI, and open PR overlap. - GitHub PR #391 at b4440ddf: scan_ruby, scan_js, lint, and test all SUCCESS; gh reports MERGEABLE. - Focused local verification with Homebrew Ruby PATH passed: bin/rails test test/helpers/stage_agents_helper_test.rb test/integration/board_card_stage_avatars_test.rb test/views/consolidated_timeline_test.rb test/system/task_timeline_mascot_history_test.rb => 87 runs, 371 assertions, 0 failures. - Local URL http://localhost:3004/tasks/evolve-demo-charmander-line returned 200; rendered HTML includes assembled Steffon-only card plus Evolve reel markers for Charmeleon->Charizard triggered by Steffon.

Scout report: request-changes - Request changes: happy path and CI are green, but third_evolution false-positives on skipped submit gate. Reporter: jasper Outcome: request-changes Findings: - BLOCKER app/helpers/stage_agents_helper.rb:441 treats any assembled snapshot change as an Evolve moment. The supported direct building->assembled path evolves only Charmander->Charmeleon, yet the helper renders an Evolve card, violating the only-third-stage acceptance criterion. Questions: - none Checks: - GitHub PR #391 targets release, is open/non-draft, mergeStateStatus CLEAN, and CI scan_ruby/scan_js/lint/test all succeeded at e1d6536378779b18334b23cedc1f30471e266c29. - Inspected task metadata, PR body, changed helper/view/tests, and open PR overlap; #395 also touches _consolidated_timeline.html.erb but #391 is clean against current release. - Reproduced locally in the feature worktree with RAILS_ENV=test mise exec ruby@3.3.11 -- bin/rails runner: direct assemble probe returned third_evolution [charmander,charmeleon] and block_stages included evolve.

Scout report: merge-ready - Light review found no blockers; PR meets inline span metadata and clear-grade stability scope with CI, targeted tests, DoR, local render, and current release merge safety green. Reporter: jasper Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - non-blocker: blocked draft PR #379 heartbeat-span-polish overlaps these heartbeat files and conflicts if revived; PR #386 itself merges cleanly into current origin/release. Questions: - none Checks: - GitHub PR #386 is open, non-draft, base release, mergeable, with lint/scan_js/scan_ruby/test all successful. - Local targeted test slice passed: 54 runs, 245 assertions, 0 failures. - bin/dor-check inline-span-badges passed and task metadata shows expected=2 run=5 checks. - Local URL http://localhost:3005/alex/heartbeat/spans returned 200 and rendered event-inline-action-count, event-inline-status, event-key-method, and event-grade-clear hooks. - git merge-tree origin/release HEAD produced a clean synthetic merge tree; git diff --check was clean.

Scout report: request-changes - Light review found inline metadata present, but the PR misses an acceptance requirement and is not merge-safe. Reporter: jasper Outcome: request-changes Findings: - Blocker: the existing Status / Task column is not unchanged; _event_table renames it to Command / Task and removes the status/action content from that column. - Blocker: bin/dor-check inline-span-badges fails because task metadata only records the manual check, with missing component and exact-code full-suite/rubocop evidence. - Blocker: PR #386 conflicts with open PR #379 heartbeat-span-polish in heartbeat event partials/styles/tests, so it can collide with another agent's work. Questions: - none Checks: - GitHub PR #386 targets release, is mergeable against current release, and CI jobs lint, scan_js, scan_ruby, and test all pass. - Local targeted component/integration command passed: bin/rails test test/views/heartbeat_event_table_test.rb test/integration/alex_heartbeat_test.rb test/integration/heartbeat_event_grade_test.rb (54 runs, 245 assertions). - Manual HTML probe of http://localhost:3005/alex/heartbeat/spans shows event-inline-action-count and event-inline-status in title rows, but header is Command / Task rather than Status / Task. - git merge-tree --write-tree origin/feat/heartbeat-span-polish origin/feat/inline-span-badges exits 1 with conflicts in _event_feedback_cell, _event_table, _styles, and heartbeat_event_table_test.