McRitchie Studio

Scout report: merge-ready - Doc/operating-model seat: atomic-capture-hook.md is accurate for the provider-adapter split, Codex capture path, and prod ATOMIC_CAPTURE_URL default; Claude backward-compat preserved. No blockers. Reporter: alex Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - Codex PostToolUse capture WILL fire: release already wires a Codex [[hooks.PostToolUse]] (matcher=Bash) for mascot repaint, so the runtime fires that event — not dead automation. - agent_context 'Codex hooks do not call atomic-capture-hook' describes the BEFORE state; PR wires Codex PostToolUse capture + Stop close-open (install-agent-docs) — no contradiction. - Claude path backward compatible: normalize_event only branches on provider==codex; turn_usage/outcome_for/resolve_assistant_turn preserve Claude semantics (acceptance #3 met). - NON-BLOCKER doc completeness: outcome row (doc:51) omits Codex string 'Process exited with code N' detection; Tests section (doc:291) omits new provider-adapter/Codex tests. Questions: - none Checks: - Doc lines 25 & 162 both updated localhost:3000 -> https://mcritchie.studio; no sibling docs reference ATOMIC_CAPTURE_URL (no stale cross-refs).

Scout report: request-changes - Code is correct, well-tested, docs-current, backward-compatible for all 5 criteria; CI green and touched tests verified green. BUT the DoR gate (mine) does not pass: full-suite/rubocop evidence lines are malformed and unit/integration tier tags are absent. Fix is a fast re-cert, not code rework. Reporter: carl Outcome: request-changes Findings: - BLOCKER (gate): checks_run cert lines are '[full-suite] ... green at 6fa63a721915' / '[rubocop] ...' — the gate only recognizes '[full-suite@<fp>]' (full_suite_gate.rb EVIDENCE_RE l79); fingerprint isn't inside the brackets so it never parses. dor-check reports full-suite+rubocop MISSING even from the exact branch tree (6fa63a72...=tree). Re-run bin/full-suite-check standardize-llm-logging from the branch to stamp valid evidence. - BLOCKER (gate): backend shape requires [unit]+[integration] dor_tiers; checks_run has neither tag. Tests EXIST and pass, but add tier-tagged checks_run lines (--checks REPLACES, so include the full-suite/rubocop lines too). - NON-BLOCKER: outcome_for (bin/atomic-capture-hook ~l844) flags any String output containing 'Process exited with code N!=0' as ERROR — a successful Codex tool whose output echoes that phrase (e.g. a test runner) would false-flag error. Conservative, low-impact. Questions: - none Checks: - Ran touched test files from branch tree 6fa63a72: atomic_capture_hook_test 48 runs/0 failures (incl new Codex tests), atomic_event_cli_test 53 runs/0 failures. Confirmed cert free-text fp == branch-head tree. - Verified Claude backward-compat: provider_for routes Claude events to unchanged path; turn_usage math identical for Claude payload shape; read_assistant_turn refactor is behavior-preserving.

Code is merge-ready — all 5 acceptance criteria MET, CI green, Claude backward-compat preserved, docs accurate. The block is the DoR gate (evidence recording only, NOT a code rework). Two must-fix items: 1) MALFORMED full-suite/rubocop cert. checks_run has '[full-suite] ... green at 6fa63a721915' / '[rubocop] ... green at 6fa63a721915', but the gate (bin/lib/full_suite_gate.rb EVIDENCE_RE) only accepts the fingerprint INSIDE the brackets: [full-suite@6fa63a721915] / [rubocop@6fa63a721915]. dor-check reports both MISSING — confirmed run from the exact branch tree 6fa63a7219, so this is NOT a stale-cert false positive, the evidence line is unparseable. Fix: run 'bin/full-suite-check standardize-llm-logging' from the branch to stamp valid cert lines. 2) MISSING required tier tags. Backend shape requires [unit] + [integration] tagged checks_run lines; neither present (the tests exist and pass — recording only). Add them. NOTE: bin/task update --checks REPLACES the list, so re-include the valid cert lines AND the tier lines in one update. Fix opportunistically in the same pass (non-blockers, don't merit their own loop): 3) bin/atomic-capture-hook ~L844 outcome_for: a SUCCESSFUL Codex tool whose String output echoes 'Process exited with code N' (N!=0) is mis-flagged ERROR — tighten the match. 4) docs/agents/system/atomic-capture-hook.md polish: add the Codex string-based 'Process exited with code N' signal to the outcome-field row (~:51); mention the new provider-adapter/Codex-normalization/transcript-recovery unit tests in the Tests section (~:291). After re-cert, dor-check will pass — resubmit and post a note --resolves-feedback.

Resolved Avi feedback: checks_run now has required unit/integration tier tags plus parseable full-suite/rubocop cert lines; tightened Codex string outcome parsing and updated capture docs/tests.

Scout report: merge-ready - Light review found no blockers; Codex/Claude capture, installer wiring, docs, CI, and merge safety look ready. Reporter: alex Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - BLOCKERS: none. - NON-BLOCKER: long Codex transcripts may still leave model nil when model metadata falls outside the transcript tail; capture degrades by omitting model and this does not affect activity/action persistence. - QUESTIONS: none. Questions: - none Checks: - Read AGENTS.md, README, Avi light SOP, Alex role, atomic-capture/Codex docs; inspected PR body, diff, changed files, tests, CI, and merge safety. - GitHub CI green (lint, scan_js, scan_ruby, test); PR #448 is open, clean/mergeable, base release, head 68f1c3e. - Did not run gates per light-review SOP; relied on reported unit/integration/full-suite/rubocop checks and code/test inspection.

Scout report: merge-ready - Primary review found no blockers; PR satisfies LLM logging acceptance and is ready for Avi to advance. Reporter: carl Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - blockers: none - non-blocker: Codex model can remain nil on long local transcripts when model metadata is outside the parsed tail; actions, activity pins, and token usage still persist. Questions: - none Checks: - DOR: bin/dor-check standardize-llm-logging passed; cert tree 4940b56 matches HEAD tree for 68f1c3e. - Focused tests passed: atomic_capture_hook, agent_api, install_agent_skills, atomic_event_cli. - GitHub CI green on PR #448: lint, scan_js, scan_ruby, test; mergeStateStatus CLEAN; no open PR or local worktree file overlaps.

pr-review moved standardize-llm-logging to reviewed after carl + alex reported merge-ready. Left for Steffon QA. Reports: - carl: merge-ready - Primary review found no blockers; PR satisfies LLM logging acceptance and is ready for Avi to advance. - alex: merge-ready - Light review found no blockers; Codex/Claude capture, installer wiring, docs, CI, and merge safety look ready.