McRitchie Studio

Scout report: merge-ready - Light read (docs/coherence lens): acceptance 5/5 met; UsagePricing is genuinely single-source (repo grep finds no other rate table); PR body matches diff; cert tree fresh; CI green Reporter: alex Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - Non-blocker: bin/atomic-capture-hook turn_usage comment (~line 513) still says cache-write 'true rate is 1.25x' — new SoT establishes 2.0x (1h TTL); stale comment in untouched file, fix on next touch - Question: briefing said board costs shift ~down, but fixtures shift slightly UP (0.1928->0.1936, 0.1038->0.1040) from the 1.25x->2.0x write correction; PR makes no direction claim, module documents /usage-meter reconciliation rationale Questions: - none Checks: - diff-vs-acceptance: all 5 criteria verified in lib/usage_pricing.rb, app/models/agent_action.rb, lib/agent_session_usage.rb, test/lib/usage_pricing_test.rb - single-source grep: no MODEL_RATES/PRICING/multiplier constants outside module; no token-to-dollar math in views/JS/helpers; live docs name no removed constant - cert fingerprint = PR head tree ad5a8571 (tree equality verified); CI 4/4 SUCCESS; PR open non-draft base release

Scout report: merge-ready - Light docs-lens review: one UsagePricing SoT, both callers delegate, rates verified against claude-api reference (opus-4-8 5/25, cache read 0.10x, 1h write 2.0x), fixture math checks out, no stale MODEL_RATES/PRICING refs on branch, no doc drift Reporter: alex Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - Rates + multipliers match authoritative Anthropic pricing reference exactly - Old constants fully removed; only historical comment + kept ATOMIC_ACTION_MODEL_RATES env name remain (intentional) - Docs carry no pricing constants; atomic-capture-hook.md cache-read-tier claim still accurate Questions: - none Checks: - gh pr view 455: OPEN, not draft, base release, CI 4/4 SUCCESS, MERGEABLE - git grep on FETCH_HEAD: no stale pricing constant references

Scout report: merge-ready - Light read clean: all 7 acceptance criteria trace to the diff; CI green; PR open non-draft into release. Two non-blocking notes. Reporter: alex Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - checks_run says 'promote tests green' but no test asserts crew-promote-slot/crew-promoted (experimental hover flourish; existing crew suite green) — add an assertion or reword - ERB comment nit in _stage_agent_avatars: bare % in '150% hover reveal' — safe (no %>) but house rule prefers zero % in ERB comment bodies Questions: - none Checks: - diff vs 7 acceptance criteria: all present - PR state OPEN, base release, not draft, CI 4/4 green - no stale doc refs to removed footer PR link / Local Demo button

Scout report: merge-ready - LIGHT (docs lens): all 3 ACs met, faithfully mirrors the shipped /people & /teams filter idiom, stays ui-only. One PR-body drift nit + one coverage note; no blockers. Reporter: alex Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - NIT/doc-drift: PR body Verification bullet says 'x-show' but impl uses the filteredSessions getter (style.display toggle) — no per-item x-show exists. Reword to '(search input + data-name + filteredSessions getter)'. - Non-blocking: live-filter JS (empty-query show-all + narrowing) has no automated coverage — component tests assert server-rendered structure only (Nokogiri can't run Alpine); consistent with ui-only component tier + prod idiom + local proof. - Optional nit: add compact_time_ago(now-60)=='1m ago' to pin the upper edge of the new 'just now' window; the now-50 assertion already covers the changed 45-59s case. Questions: - none Checks: - 3 ACs satisfied: search input gated on sessions.any?, x-model.debounce.300ms sessionQuery + getter narrows by data-name, empty query (!q) shows all. - compact_time_ago comment correction accurate: fn renders m/h/d/w + 'just now', never an 's' unit — old '(s/m/h/d/w)' was wrong, new comment right.

Scout report: merge-ready - Light review found no blockers; Codex/Claude capture, installer wiring, docs, CI, and merge safety look ready. Reporter: alex Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - BLOCKERS: none. - NON-BLOCKER: long Codex transcripts may still leave model nil when model metadata falls outside the transcript tail; capture degrades by omitting model and this does not affect activity/action persistence. - QUESTIONS: none. Questions: - none Checks: - Read AGENTS.md, README, Avi light SOP, Alex role, atomic-capture/Codex docs; inspected PR body, diff, changed files, tests, CI, and merge safety. - GitHub CI green (lint, scan_js, scan_ruby, test); PR #448 is open, clean/mergeable, base release, head 68f1c3e. - Did not run gates per light-review SOP; relied on reported unit/integration/full-suite/rubocop checks and code/test inspection.

Scout report: merge-ready - Doc/operating-model seat: atomic-capture-hook.md is accurate for the provider-adapter split, Codex capture path, and prod ATOMIC_CAPTURE_URL default; Claude backward-compat preserved. No blockers. Reporter: alex Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - Codex PostToolUse capture WILL fire: release already wires a Codex [[hooks.PostToolUse]] (matcher=Bash) for mascot repaint, so the runtime fires that event — not dead automation. - agent_context 'Codex hooks do not call atomic-capture-hook' describes the BEFORE state; PR wires Codex PostToolUse capture + Stop close-open (install-agent-docs) — no contradiction. - Claude path backward compatible: normalize_event only branches on provider==codex; turn_usage/outcome_for/resolve_assistant_turn preserve Claude semantics (acceptance #3 met). - NON-BLOCKER doc completeness: outcome row (doc:51) omits Codex string 'Process exited with code N' detection; Tests section (doc:291) omits new provider-adapter/Codex tests. Questions: - none Checks: - Doc lines 25 & 162 both updated localhost:3000 -> https://mcritchie.studio; no sibling docs reference ATOMIC_CAPTURE_URL (no stale cross-refs).

Resolved Shannon's same-session reviewer-fanout usage blocker: bin/atomic-event usage baseline is now lane-aware (per agent lane, not the single session marker), and a window shared by concurrent lanes reports BLANK usage (measured_usage? false) instead of a double-counted value — honors the PR's no-fake-measured-usage principle; separate subagent sessions still measure normally. New [unit] regression test_unit_concurrent_same_session_lanes_report_blank_usage proves both concurrent lanes blank while the sole-lane test still measures (no over-blanking). full-suite green @651b15fc, rubocop clean, CI 4/4 green. Carl's merge-ready core (measured usage + supervisor attribution) unchanged.

Scout report: request-changes - Light review found no derivation/cache code defect, but migration lane metadata is missing while the PR ships a Rails migration and schema change. Reporter: alex Outcome: request-changes Findings: - Blocker: task requires_migration=false and risk_tags omit migration even though PR adds db/migrate/20260707120000_create_nfl_team_total_projections.rb and modifies db/schema.rb; exclusive-lanes says migration/schema tasks must enter backend_migration. - Merge safety: PR #445 also edits db/schema.rb; git merge-tree shows a schema-version conflict if #445 and #440 are combined without rebasing/serializing. Questions: - Should Avi clear the draft state only after the migration flag/lane ordering is corrected? Checks: - Inspected AGENTS.md, PR light SOP, README, RUNBOOK, nfl-pipeline docs, task JSON, PR metadata/diff, CI rollup, CSV counts, qa-intake, and open PR file overlap. - CI rollup for 406aac6 is green: scan_ruby, scan_js, lint, and test all passed; I did not rerun gates.

Scout report: merge-ready - LIGHT read: scoped ui-only hover polish; acceptance met, focus-within genuinely fires, docs coherent. Reporter: alex Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - Scope clean: 2 files (avatars partial +10/-3, integration test +7/-2), no unrelated churn. - Focus criterion met: group-focus-within added; group card ancestor has focusable <a>/buttons so it fires; no outline suppression. - Inline comment updated coherently; no ERB comment trap (no % in <%# %> body). - Non-blocker for UI-primary: eyeball scale-110 + looser overlap on densest 4-lane Deploy card for visual spill; origin-anchoring + translate-x=0 test guard make it unlikely. Questions: - none Checks: - CI green (test/lint/scan_ruby/scan_js SUCCESS); full-suite+rubocop cert stamped d0185ea3.

Added --finding to the command examples so the policy matches the coupled #431 verb; tightened the paging line to specify the harness tool-results/ spill files (real source paging kept).

Reconciled kind feature->docs: deliverable is a pure markdown operating-model module (docs/agents/modules/result-distillation.md) + one index.md line, no code surface. shape=backend was a mis-fit; dor-check now passes via the designed EXEMPT-kind path. checks_run carries a [full-suite-bypass] record; the full Rails suite was not run (no runtime surface to certify).

Manager review approved: IN-clause order fix (index_by + filter_map preserves next_slugs order); red-green regression proof (branches seeded reversed, deterministic across 3 seeds); confirmed only order-dependent IN fan-out in the model; CI green 4 checks; dor-check DoR-to-Merge met.

Fresh CI GREEN at head 0f9159d6 after de-flaking the review_events e2e (scoped the Docs-link click by href + wait for the menu to open). Re-certified at head. The stale-cert was a false positive (fingerprint = head's tree). dor-check: DoR-to-Merge met, CI green 4 checks. Content approved by Alex (all 4 acceptance criteria met). Advancing to reviewed.

BLOCK — red required gate + stale cert. The docs/script CONTENT is approvable; the block is purely CI + cert, so a clean re-push should clear it. (a) CI 'test' is RED at head 6daea3dd. scan_ruby/scan_js/lint all green; only the 'test' job failed, on ONE system-lane e2e: ReviewEventsTest#test_[e2e]_operator_opens_review_process_hub_from_deployment_link_menu (test/system/review_events_test.rb:48) — 'expected "/stages" to equal "/review_events"'. This is NOT your code: that test file AND the view it drives (app/views/tasks/_deployment_link_menu.html.erb) are byte-identical to origin/release and are NOT in this PR's diff (your +511/-125 is bin/pr-review + docs + doc-tests — no routes/views). CI also logged a chromedriver 149 vs chrome 150 mismatch → a classic Capybara mis-click (the 'Stages' link sits directly above 'Docs' in the same dropdown). Flaky/unrelated e2e, not a defect. FIX: rebase on latest origin/release and re-push to trigger a fresh CI run. If it reproduces, it's flaky on release itself — de-flake it (scope the click to the Docs link / add an explicit wait / assert the link before clicking) or split to a separate bug; don't let it gate this docs PR. Flagging to Avi/Steffon as a possible release-branch flake. (b) The cert is STALE. checks_run claims [full-suite@53b1959…] 'test test:system green', but head is 6daea3dd (4 commits) and 53b1959 is not in the branch — so the 'system green' claim doesn't hold at head, and CI at head proves the system lane is (flakily) red. Re-cert the FULL suite (incl. system) at head after the rebase and update checks_run. (c) CONTENT is CLEAN — no doc/script defects. All 4 acceptance criteria met: (1) Avi supervises / never reviews code — consistent across role.md, mission.md, devops-cycle-design.md (§1.2 + table row + clarifications), parallel-agent-devops.md, heartbeats.md, pr-review.md, the pr-review-sop.md primitive, full-cycle.md, deploy-with-task.md; (2) primary+light spawn IN PARALLEL as siblings under Avi — consistent everywhere, and bin/pr-review genuinely launches both via Process.spawn before waiting (verified); (3) separate pr-review-primary.md + pr-review-light.md role SOPs exist, STAND ALONE (no design-doc pointers; Related links only registered SOPs + the primitive), and are registered in BOTH index.md registry tables; (4) bin/pr-review narrates 'select primary+light reviewers' (never 'summon Avi'), asserted by the command test. Stale-reference sweep: git grep at head found ZERO lingering 'spawns the light' / 'nested chain' / 'nested cascade' / 'hands the lane to the PRIMARY' anywhere in docs/agents; pr-review-slow.md (untouched) defers cleanly to pr-review.md as 'the serialized supervisor path'. Tests are meaningful, not hollow: review_lane_docs_test tripwires pair positive asserts with refutes of the old model across 7 docs; pr_review_command_test shells out to real bin/pr-review and its fast-mode codex_before_first_move==4 assertion uniquely requires non-blocking parallel spawn. NET: docs/script content is approvable; the block is purely red CI (flaky unrelated e2e) + stale cert — rebase on release, re-push for a clean CI run, and re-cert the full suite at head.

Scout report: conductor-review - Light review found the border glow primitive implementation code-clean for this task, but PR #415 is still draft and shared with blocked sibling deployment-rainbow-border, so Avi should reconcile readiness before reviewed. Reporter: alex Outcome: conductor-review Findings: - No code blockers: .studio-border-glow owns the masked border and halo pseudo-elements, while submitted/reviewed/assembled/release cards only configure CSS variables and stage palettes. - Reduced motion is handled at the primitive level by disabling animation on .studio-border-glow::before and ::after; submitted also remains non-animated through its stage variable. - Merge/admin gate: GitHub reports PR #415 mergeable with CI green, but isDraft=true, qa-intake labels it avi-ready-draft, and the same PR references blocked task deployment-rainbow-border. - Task DoR metadata gate: bin/dor-check border-glow-primitive reports stale full-suite/rubocop fingerprints for this task record, despite current PR CI being green. Questions: - none Checks: - [component] Inspected app/assets/tailwind/application.css and task/current-release views against primitive and deployment palette acceptance criteria. - [integration] curl -fsS http://localhost:3004/deployments confirmed studio-border-glow on confirming, submitted, reviewed, and assembled cards; /up returned 200. - [ci] gh pr checks 415 reports scan_ruby, scan_js, lint, and test all pass at current head e5c50682. - [merge-safety] git diff --check clean; git merge-tree origin/release origin/feat/deployment-rainbow-border produced a clean tree; no same-file overlap with other open release PRs.

Scout report: merge-ready - Light UI review found the turbo-frame filter refresh scoped and merge-ready; PR #413 is mergeable with green CI and no same-file open-PR overlap. Reporter: alex Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - No blockers or non-blocking code findings. The frame wraps stats, table, pager, and sidebar while Alpine state stays outside, preserving the open sidebar and URL advancement. Questions: - none Checks: - Verified PR metadata/diff/CI, task metadata, DoR from the feature worktree, open-PR overlap, local preview 200, targeted Rails integration, and the added Playwright no-reload spec.

Scout report: request-changes - Request changes: gem release_check remains unregistered/unwrapped; focused release CLI suite is green under Ruby 3.3. Reporter: alex Outcome: request-changes Findings: - Blocker: bin/release.rb:747-752 still runs a gem release_check via sh(rc, '--build') while config/devops_test_suites.yml release_scopes has no gem scope, so gem releases miss start/result telemetry. - Non-blocker: PR #361 also touches bin/release.rb and test/lib/release_cli_test.rb; git merge-tree auto-merges the pair, but conductor should sequence the same-file overlap. Questions: - none Checks: - Ruby 3.3.11 focused run: ruby -Itest test/lib/release_cli_test.rb — 140 runs, 709 assertions, 0 failures. - bin/devops-tests --app mcritchie-studio prints the updated catalog; PR #414 is mergeable with GitHub CI success.

Scout report: merge-ready - Light review found no blockers; PR #393 satisfies hourly/subhour timer acceptance and is merge-ready for Avi. Reporter: alex Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - Blockers: none. ApplicationHelper and release_ticker JS agree on Hh MMm at one hour while keeping subhour Mm SSs display. - Merge safety: GitHub reports CLEAN/MERGEABLE, local merge-tree into origin/release is clean, and no current open PR changes the same three files. Questions: - none Checks: - [unit/component] PATH=/opt/homebrew/opt/ruby@3.3/bin:... bin/rails test test/helpers/application_helper_test.rb => 50 runs, 424 assertions, 0 failures - [gate] bin/dor-check trim-timer-seconds => DoR-to-Merge met for ui-only; ready submitted -> reviewed - [ci] GitHub CI scan_ruby, scan_js, lint, test all success at 3879b22cde642288f84c31073370b5e5dc7c86ee - [smoke] curl http://localhost:3012/up => 200

Scout report: merge-ready - Light review found no code blockers. Hourly release timers drop seconds after one hour, subhour active timers keep minute/second precision, focused tests and DoR pass, GitHub CI is green, and the current release merge-tree is clean. PR #393 is still draft, so the conductor should confirm owner intent or undraft before final advancement. Reporter: alex Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - Blockers: none. - Non-blocker/process: PR #393 remains draft and qa-intake classifies it as avi-ready-draft; conductor should confirm owner intent or mark ready before advancing. - Merge safety: #388 is already merged into release, #393 merges cleanly against current origin/release, and no open PRs touch the same changed files. Questions: - none Checks: - bin/dor-check trim-timer-seconds => DoR-to-Merge met for ui-only shape. - PATH="/opt/homebrew/opt/ruby@3.3/bin:/opt/homebrew/lib/ruby/gems/3.3.0/bin:$PATH" bin/rails test test/helpers/application_helper_test.rb => 50 runs, 424 assertions, 0 failures. - gh pr checks 393 => lint, scan_js, scan_ruby, and test all pass. - git merge-tree --write-tree origin/release origin/pr/393 => clean tree 82d2f9529eaec9a2d9c7a5f829e3c121082be267. - curl http://localhost:3012/up => 200.

Scout report: merge-ready - Light review found no code blockers; hourly timers drop seconds after one hour, subhour live timers keep minute/second precision, DoR and CI are green, and current release merge simulation is clean. Reporter: alex Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - Blockers: none. - Non-blocker: PR #393 is still draft on GitHub even though the task is submitted; conductor should account for draft state before any final stage move. - Question: none for implementation scope. Questions: - none Checks: - Read AGENTS.md, Avi pr-review SOP, modular review SOP, README, ECOSYSTEM, testing docs, and frontend docs. - Inspected task metadata, PR body/state/check rollup/comments/reviews, and changed files. - bin/rails test test/helpers/application_helper_test.rb => 50 runs, 424 assertions, 0 failures. - bin/dor-check trim-timer-seconds => DoR-to-Merge met for ui-only shape. - git merge-tree --write-tree origin/release HEAD => clean tree 82d2f9529eaec9a2d9c7a5f829e3c121082be267; curl http://localhost:3012/up => 200.