McRitchie Studio

Scout report: request-changes - Request changes: the follow-up prefill sets source shape, but HTML create/update drops task[devops][shape], so created follow-up tasks lose source shape and test-tier context. CI is green; merge ordering also needs the PR #286 route-doc conflict handled. Reporter: shannon Outcome: request-changes Findings: - blocker: app/controllers/tasks_controller.rb permits task[devops] without :shape while followup_task_from copies source.devops_shape; submitting the prefilled follow-up task drops the shape. - merge safety: PR #290 is clean against origin/release, but git merge-tree with reviewed PR #286 conflicts in docs/topics/routes-and-controllers.md. - non-blocker: GitHub reports PR #290 MERGEABLE and all CI jobs pass, but the PR is still draft/qa-intake avi-ready-draft. Questions: - none Checks: - Read AGENTS.md, qa-release SOP, repo README/RUNBOOK, DevOps task-board docs, parallel DevOps docs, task metadata, PR body, diff, changed files, tests, CI, and open PR overlap. - gh pr checks 290: scan_ruby, scan_js, lint, and test all passed. - git diff --check and git merge-tree against origin/release passed; pairwise merge-tree with PR #286 reported a route-doc conflict.

Scout report: request-changes - Guard UI and CI look clean, but the follow-up create path drops source shape on submit. Reporter: alex Outcome: request-changes Findings: - Blocker: app/controllers/tasks_controller.rb permits DevOps form fields without :shape, while followup_task_from preloads source.devops_shape and the form posts task[devops][shape]; saved follow-up tasks lose the shape/test-tier context. - Non-blocker: PR #290 is still draft, though GitHub CI is green and the branch is mergeable against release. - Merge safety: session-preflight reports a clean PR against origin/release with same-file overlap in #286/#282/#289, so merge order should be watched but no current conflict is present. Questions: - none Checks: - Read AGENTS.md, README.md, RUNBOOK.md, devops-cycle-design, devops-task-board, and parallel-agent-devops docs. - Inspected task metadata, PR body, changed files, tests, CI, qa-intake, and session-preflight output. - Ran bin/agent-worktree test mcritchie-studio review-followup-guard -- test/controllers/tasks_controller_test.rb -n '/review followup|new followup/' => 3 runs, 16 assertions, 0 failures.

Avi Heartbeat blocked review: shannon: request-changes - Request changes: the follow-up prefill sets source shape, but HTML create/update drops task[devops][shape], so created follow-up tasks lose source shape and test-tier context. CI is green; merge ordering also needs the PR #286 route-doc conflict handled.; alex: request-changes - Guard UI and CI look clean, but the follow-up create path drops source shape on submit.

Scout report: request-changes - Request changes: code-level prior blockers appear fixed, but PR #290 is not review-ready because DoR-to-merge fails on stale full-suite/RuboCop evidence for current head and the PR remains draft. Reporter: shannon Outcome: request-changes Findings: - blocker: bin/dor-check review-followup-guard fails for head 70cecca because [full-suite@5eed874979930f8654029e83358bd59a4b27c0e6] and [rubocop@5eed874979930f8654029e83358bd59a4b27c0e6] are stale; rerun bin/full-suite-check review-followup-guard and record fresh fingerprint-bound evidence. - blocker: GitHub and qa-intake report PR #290 is still draft/avi-ready-draft, so Avi should not advance it until the owner marks it ready after refreshing gate evidence. - non-blocker: prior shape-preservation feedback is addressed in app/controllers/tasks_controller.rb; create/update now permit devops shape, and the focused controller regression passed locally. - merge safety: PR #290 is CLEAN/MERGEABLE against origin/release, CI is green, and merge-tree probes with overlapping PRs #286, #292, #289, and #282 all returned clean; same-file overlap remains advisory. Questions: - none Checks: - Read AGENTS.md, qa-release SOP, README.md, RUNBOOK.md, devops-cycle-design, devops-task-board, testing docs, Shannon/Alex roles, task metadata, PR body/comments, diff, changed files, docs, tests, CI, and merge safety. - gh pr checks 290: scan_ruby, scan_js, lint, and test all passed; gh pr view reports base=release, head=70cecca, mergeStateStatus=CLEAN, isDraft=true. - bin/dor-check review-followup-guard failed DoR-to-Merge due stale full-suite/RuboCop stamps; bin/session-preflight passed with same-file overlap warnings. - Ruby 3.3 PATH bin/rails test test/controllers/tasks_controller_test.rb -n '/review followup|new followup|followup task shape|devops handoff metadata|devops shape/' passed: 6 runs, 40 assertions. - Local proof http://localhost:3018/tasks/review-followup-demo returned 200 and rendered the Review in progress guard; git diff --check passed.

Scout report: merge-ready - Merge-ready light review: guard UI, follow-up prefill, shape persistence, docs, CI, DoR, and merge safety check out; no blockers found. PR is still draft on GitHub, so mark ready before actual merge. Reporter: alex Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - Blockers: none found in the task guard, follow-up task prefill, devops shape persistence, docs, or tests. - Non-blocker: PR #290 is still draft; Avi selected it for review and qa-intake otherwise reports merge=CLEAN/local=up. - Merge safety: route-doc overlap was removed; merge-tree is clean against release, review-process-hub, feedback-resolution-state, review-comment-taxonomy, and deployment-grid-timers. Questions: - none Checks: - [component] bin/rails test test/controllers/tasks_controller_test.rb -n '/review followup|new followup|followup task shape|devops handoff metadata|devops shape/' -> 6 runs, 40 assertions, 0 failures - [ci] GitHub checks scan_ruby, scan_js, lint, and test are all passing on 70cecca - [gate] bin/dor-check review-followup-guard -> DoR-to-Merge met; full suite + rubocop certified at 5eed87497993 - [local] http://localhost:3018/up returned 200; /tasks/review-followup-demo renders data-test=review-followup-guard

Avi Heartbeat blocked review: shannon: request-changes - Request changes: code-level prior blockers appear fixed, but PR #290 is not review-ready because DoR-to-merge fails on stale full-suite/RuboCop evidence for current head and the PR remains draft.; alex: merge-ready - Merge-ready light review: guard UI, follow-up prefill, shape persistence, docs, CI, DoR, and merge safety check out; no blockers found. PR is still draft on GitHub, so mark ready before actual merge.

Scout report: merge-ready - Fresh conductor review found the prior blockers resolved; PR #290 is non-draft, CI/DoR/focused checks are green, and merge-tree is clean. Reporter: avi Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - Prior feedback is addressed: follow-up task shape now persists through HTML create/update, and the route-doc overlap was removed from this PR. - PR #290 is open, non-draft, targets release, and GitHub reports mergeStateStatus CLEAN with all checks passing. Questions: - none Checks: - bin/dor-check review-followup-guard: DoR-to-Merge met for ui-only. - mise x ruby@3.3.11 -- bin/rails test test/controllers/tasks_controller_test.rb -n '/review followup|new followup|followup task shape|devops handoff metadata|devops shape/': 6 runs, 40 assertions, 0 failures. - git diff --check origin/release...HEAD and git merge-tree --write-tree origin/release HEAD passed.

Avi moved review-followup-guard to reviewed after a fresh conductor review. Evidence: PR #290 is non-draft, targets release, GitHub CI is green, bin/dor-check review-followup-guard passes for ui-only, focused controller regression passed under Ruby 3.3.11 with 6 runs and 40 assertions, and git diff --check plus merge-tree against origin/release are clean. Left for release assembly; not merged by this review pass.

Resolved: concern was process-only (PR #290 draft + stale full-suite/RuboCop evidence for head). Both reviewers confirmed code-level blockers fixed (alex: merge-ready, no blockers). The PR has since been marked ready and merged to main, so the draft/stale-evidence conditions no longer apply.