McRitchie Studio

Scout report: merge-ready - Light review found no code blockers for the roster shiny/evolution UI. Acceptance is covered in the incremental diff and component test; CI and DoR are green. Reporter: alex Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - Blockers: none found. - Non-blocker: PR #384 intentionally stacks on #383/base-level-spawn-pool; if both are reviewed, release ordering should merge #383 first by position, but conductor should keep that order visible. - Questions: none. Questions: - none Checks: - Read AGENTS.md, Avi pr-review SOP, pr-review-sop module, README, RUNBOOK, and relevant frontend/testing/routes docs. - Inspected task metadata, PR body, changed files, CI, mergeability, worktree status, and open PR overlap. - Reviewed incremental diff over feat/base-level-spawn-pool: PokemonController, pokemon/index view, and pokemon_controller_test. - Verified gh PR #384 is open against release, mergeable CLEAN, and CI scan_ruby/scan_js/lint/test passed. - Ran bin/rails test test/controllers/pokemon_controller_test.rb: 7 runs, 31 assertions, 0 failures. - Ran bin/dor-check pokemon-roster-shiny-evolutions: DoR-to-Merge met for ui-only shape. - Curl verified http://localhost:3004/pokemon returns HTTP 200.

Scout report: conductor-review - Implementation meets the roster shiny/evolution acceptance with green CI and local checks, but PR #384 is intentionally stacked on PR #383 and needs conductor sequencing before advancement. Reporter: shannon Outcome: conductor-review Findings: - Blocker: PR #384 includes base-level-spawn-pool commit da12ec64 from submitted PR #383; do not advance or release-sweep #384 ahead of #383 or the dependency task can enter release through this PR. - Non-blocker: task-specific diff after #383 is limited to app/controllers/pokemon_controller.rb, app/views/pokemon/index.html.erb, and test/controllers/pokemon_controller_test.rb; it matches the requested list/grid shiny toggles and grid evolution circles. Questions: - none Checks: - [component] bin/rails test test/controllers/pokemon_controller_test.rb — 7 runs, 31 assertions, green locally on feat/pokemon-roster-shiny-evolutions - [dor] bin/dor-check pokemon-roster-shiny-evolutions — shape ui-only satisfied; full suite and rubocop certified in task metadata - [ci] gh pr checks 384 — lint, scan_js, scan_ruby, test all pass - [manual/browser] Playwright probe against http://localhost:3004/pokemon — list and grid click swap normal/shiny display; 122 evolution circles; Snorlax has 0 circles - [merge-safety] gh/qa-intake show #384 clean and open; task metadata explicitly says STACKED on feat/base-level-spawn-pool PR #383

pr-review deferred pokemon-roster-shiny-evolutions: conductor-review. shannon: conductor-review - Implementation meets the roster shiny/evolution acceptance with green CI and local checks, but PR #384 is intentionally stacked on PR #383 and needs conductor sequencing before advancement.; alex: merge-ready - Light review found no code blockers for the roster shiny/evolution UI. Acceptance is covered in the incremental diff and component test; CI and DoR are green.

Scout report: conductor-review - UI acceptance is covered and tests/CI are green; route to conductor because PR #384 is stacked on submitted PR #383 and includes its migration/data-model commit. Reporter: shannon Outcome: conductor-review Findings: - Non-blocker: incremental diff from feat/base-level-spawn-pool only touches pokemon controller/view/test and implements shiny toggles plus circular evolution avatars. - Conductor sequencing risk: PR #384 contains da12ec64 from base-level-spawn-pool/PR #383, so advancing or merging it before #383 would carry the parent task's migration/data-model work through the child PR. Questions: - none Checks: - bin/dor-check pokemon-roster-shiny-evolutions: ready to advance submitted -> reviewed for ui-only shape. - bin/rails test test/controllers/pokemon_controller_test.rb: 7 runs, 31 assertions, 0 failures. - GitHub PR #384: mergeable with scan_ruby, scan_js, lint, and test all successful. - git diff origin/feat/base-level-spawn-pool..origin/feat/pokemon-roster-shiny-evolutions: incremental files are app/controllers/pokemon_controller.rb, app/views/pokemon/index.html.erb, test/controllers/pokemon_controller_test.rb.

Scout report: conductor-review - Incremental roster UI meets acceptance with green checks, but PR #384 is stacked on unmerged PR #383 so Avi should sequence it after the base-family review. Reporter: alex Outcome: conductor-review Findings: - No code blocker in the task-specific diff over feat/base-level-spawn-pool: list and grid shiny toggles are wired, grid evolution circles use preloaded Pokemon rows, and single-stage cards omit circles. - Merge-safety: PR #384 contains commit da12ec64 from PR #383/base-level-spawn-pool, including migration and seed/model changes outside this task's acceptance. Questions: - none Checks: - [docs] Read AGENTS.md, README.md, RUNBOOK.md, docs/ECOSYSTEM.md, docs/topics/frontend.md, docs/topics/testing.md, and docs/agents/modules/pr-review-sop.md. - [component] bin/rails test test/controllers/pokemon_controller_test.rb passed: 7 runs, 31 assertions. - [dor] bin/dor-check pokemon-roster-shiny-evolutions passed. - [ci] gh pr checks 384 passed: scan_ruby, scan_js, lint, test. - [manual] Playwright on http://localhost:3004/pokemon confirmed grid and list click to shiny, Snorlax has 0 circles, Charmander shows Charmeleon.

pr-review deferred pokemon-roster-shiny-evolutions: conductor-review. shannon: conductor-review - UI acceptance is covered and tests/CI are green; route to conductor because PR #384 is stacked on submitted PR #383 and includes its migration/data-model commit.; alex: conductor-review - Incremental roster UI meets acceptance with green checks, but PR #384 is stacked on unmerged PR #383 so Avi should sequence it after the base-family review.

Scout report: merge-ready - Shannon primary review: PR #384 matches the shiny-toggle and evolution-circle acceptance criteria; focused component test, DoR gate, and GitHub CI are green. Reporter: shannon Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - No blockers found in the roster UI diff; list and grid both render Alpine shiny toggles, grid cards render circular next-evolution sprites, and single-stage/final cards omit evolution circles. - Merge safety note: PR #384 is stacked on reviewed PR #383 and overlaps submitted PR #385 only through the shared base evolution-data files; GitHub reports #384 CLEAN against release. Questions: - none Checks: - [component] bin/rails test test/controllers/pokemon_controller_test.rb — 7 runs, 31 assertions, 0 failures - [dor] bin/dor-check pokemon-roster-shiny-evolutions — DoR-to-Merge met, component tier green, full suite + rubocop certified at e210911f0768 - [ci] gh pr checks 384 — lint, scan_js, scan_ruby, test all pass

Scout report: merge-ready - Light review found acceptance covered and checks green; recommend merge-ready, with #383 merged first because this PR is stacked on base-level-spawn-pool. Reporter: alex Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - No blockers. Non-blocking merge-safety note: PR #384 contains PR #383 base-level-spawn-pool commit; #383 is already reviewed/green, so Steffon should merge #383 before #384 in the release sweep. Questions: - none Checks: - [component] bin/rails test test/controllers/pokemon_controller_test.rb — 7 runs, 31 assertions, green - [dor] bin/dor-check pokemon-roster-shiny-evolutions — DoR-to-Merge met for ui-only - [ci] gh pr checks 384 — lint, scan_js, scan_ruby, test all pass - [merge] PR #384 is CLEAN/MERGEABLE and git merge-tree origin/release origin/pr/384 exited clean - [manual] http://localhost:3004/pokemon returned 200; rendered list/grid shiny toggles and evolution-circle markup

Stacked on base PR #383 (base-level-spawn-pool), now reviewed and riding the next qa-release sweep. Reviewers (shannon+alex) found the roster shiny/evolution UI green and acceptance-complete — the only hold is sequencing: #384's branch carries #383's migration/data-model commit, so it must not be swept before #383 lands. After #383 merges to release, rebase feat/pokemon-roster-shiny-evolutions onto release (dropping #383's commits), confirm CI green, and resubmit.

Avi approved (conductor decision, operator-confirmed): batch the evolution epic. #384 rides Steffon's next qa-release sweep with base #383 and sibling #385, ordered #383->#384->#385. Shared base commit da12ec64 is an identical SHA (git dedups on merge); #384's files (pokemon_controller, pokemon/index.html.erb) are disjoint from #385's. Ready for the sweep.