McRitchie Studio

PR #276 needs rework before release merge: remove the unrelated releases.duration_* schema drift from db/schema.rb or include the owning migration/task in this release. This PR's only migration adds session_mascots.parent_session_id, but db/schema.rb also claims release duration columns that origin/release has no migration for, leaving committed schema ahead of production/migrations. After fixing schema to contain only this task's migration output, rerun the targeted session mascot/API/CLI tests plus full suite/rubocop or refresh checks, then rerun bin/dor-check evolutionary-subagent-mascots.

Implement the full accepted evolutionary workflow scope: persist evolutionary outcome scoring, make mascot profiles drive reviewer assignment, reflect outcomes in the archive story, document the workflow, and add scoring regression tests. Current PR only adds parent_session_id/evolution-tree session mascot allocation plus docs/tests for that path.

Scope clarification: PR #276 implements the accepted task scope currently recorded on evolutionary-subagent-mascots: parent evolution-tree subagent mascot allocation, sibling de-dupe, single-member reuse, exhausted-tree fallback, and tests. The latest QA feedback about evolutionary outcome scoring, mascot profiles driving reviewer assignment, archive story outcomes, docs, and scoring regressions appears to describe a broader workflow not present in this task's acceptance criteria or agent_context. Recommendation: re-review PR #276 against the recorded acceptance criteria and split that broader workflow into a new designed task if desired.

PR #276 is not ready for release review: it is 19 commits behind origin/release and GitHub reports merge conflicts. session-preflight also reports PR merge state DIRTY, same-file overlap with merged review-events/release-dashboard work, and installed qa-release skill/doc drift. Rebase on origin/release, resolve conflicts preserving current release branch behavior, rerun session-preflight, backend unit/integration checks, full suite/rubocop evidence as needed, dor-check, then resubmit.

Reworked PR #276 after QA bounce: rebased feat/evolutionary-subagent-mascots onto origin/release, resolved the schema conflict by preserving the release schema version and session_mascots.parent_session_id index, reran focused backend tests, full-suite-check, rubocop, dor-check, and session-preflight. PR is now ahead 1 / behind 0; GitHub checks are running from the refreshed forced push.

Scout report: request-changes - Code review found no implementation blocker and focused tests passed locally, but the task is not merge-ready because DoR metadata is missing and the local proof URL returns 500. Reporter: carl Outcome: request-changes Findings: - Blocker: bin/dor-check evolutionary-subagent-mascots reports missing tagged unit/integration checks plus fingerprinted full-suite/rubocop evidence on the task record; checks_run currently only records CI. - Blocker: http://localhost:3004/up returns 500; logs show a pending release-duration migration, and qa-intake marks PR #276 needs-agent for local stack health. - Non-blocker: PR #276 is clean against release and GitHub CI passes, but preflight flags same-file overlap with PR #287 docs/agents/modules/app-registry.md and PR #282 bin/task/test/lib/task_cli_test.rb; merge order should be watched. Questions: - none Checks: - Reviewed AGENTS.md, README, RUNBOOK, devops review SOP, task metadata, PR body, diff, tests, CI, preflight, qa-intake, and merge state. - Ran bin/agent-worktree test mcritchie-studio evolutionary-subagent-mascots -- test/models/session_mascot_test.rb test/controllers/api/v1/sessions_controller_test.rb test/lib/task_cli_test.rb test/commands/codex_session_title_test.rb: 92 runs, 325 assertions, 0 failures.

Scout report: request-changes - Code and CI look healthy, but the production task still fails DoR and local intake, so Avi should request a handoff metadata/local-stack fix before review advancement. Reporter: alex Outcome: request-changes Findings: - Blocker: bin/dor-check evolutionary-subagent-mascots reports DoR-to-Merge NOT met because devops.checks_run only records CI, with required unit/integration and fingerprint-bound full-suite/rubocop evidence missing for the current code. - Blocker: refreshed qa-intake still marks PR #276 needs-agent because http://localhost:3004/up returns 500 from a pending base migration, so the recorded local review URL is not inspectable. - Non-blocker: the implementation matches the acceptance criteria for parent evolution-tree allocation, sibling de-dupe, single-member reuse, and exhausted-tree fallback. - Non-blocker: same-file overlap exists with PR #287 on docs/agents/modules/app-registry.md and PR #282 on bin/task plus test/lib/task_cli_test.rb, but current merge-tree against origin/release is clean. Questions: - none Checks: - Reviewed AGENTS.md, Avi Heartbeat SOP, README/RUNBOOK, ECOSYSTEM, app-registry/culture docs, task metadata, PR body/comments, diff, changed files, tests, CI, and merge safety. - GitHub PR #276 is open against release, not draft, CLEAN/MERGEABLE, with scan_ruby, scan_js, lint, and test all successful on head 29d2f755c339. - Local merge safety passed: git merge-tree --write-tree origin/release origin/pr/276 succeeded; git diff --check found no whitespace errors. - Local targeted test rerun passed under Ruby 3.3.11: 92 runs, 325 assertions, 0 failures across session mascot, sessions API, task CLI, and Codex title hook tests. - Local proof checks found qa-intake needs-agent and curl http://localhost:3004/up returned ActiveRecord::PendingMigrationError for 20260629053000_add_duration_cache_to_releases.rb.

Avi Heartbeat blocked review: carl: request-changes - Code review found no implementation blocker and focused tests passed locally, but the task is not merge-ready because DoR metadata is missing and the local proof URL returns 500.; alex: request-changes - Code and CI look healthy, but the production task still fails DoR and local intake, so Avi should request a handoff metadata/local-stack fix before review advancement.

Resolved QA blocker: repaired the isolated worktree development DB migration marker, verified http://localhost:3004/up returns 200, recorded unit/integration tiers, reran full-suite-check, and DoR now passes at fingerprint 556418bce6fc.

Scout report: merge-ready - No blockers found. PR #276 satisfies the mascot allocation acceptance criteria, has green CI, passes local focused tests and DoR, and remains clean against release. Reporter: carl Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - blockers: none. - non-blocker: same-file overlap exists with open PRs on bin/task, test/lib/task_cli_test.rb, and docs/agents/modules/app-registry.md, but preflight and GitHub mergeability are clean. - questions: none. Questions: - none Checks: - Read AGENTS.md, ECOSYSTEM.md, README.md, DevOps review docs, testing docs, and the changed app-registry docs. - Inspected task metadata, PR body, comments, changed files, schema migration, allocator/API/CLI/Codex hook wiring, and tests. - Verified GitHub CI success, PR mergeStateStatus CLEAN/MERGEABLE, localhost:3004/up 200, session-preflight pass, dor-check pass, and focused Rails tests: 92 runs, 325 assertions.

Scout report: request-changes - Light review found no code blocker, but DoR-to-merge currently refuses the task because recorded full-suite/rubocop evidence is stale for the current PR code. Reporter: alex Outcome: request-changes Findings: - Blocker: bin/dor-check evolutionary-subagent-mascots reports full-suite and rubocop evidence stale for current code; refresh recorded bin/full-suite-check evidence or record an explicit accepted bypass before advancing review. - Non-blocker: implementation and tests cover parent evolution-tree allocation, sibling de-duplication while available, single-member reuse, and exhausted-tree fallback. - Non-blocker: sibling open PRs overlap files (#292 bin/task and test/lib/task_cli_test.rb; #287 docs/agents/modules/app-registry.md); GitHub says this PR is clean against release, but merge order may require rebase if those land first. Questions: - none Checks: - Read AGENTS.md, repo README/RUNBOOK, app-registry status-line docs, and Avi Heartbeat SOP. - Reviewed PR #276 body, changed files, migration/schema, docs, tests, CI rollup, and merge state. - GitHub Actions passed scan_ruby, scan_js, lint, and test on PR #276; gh reports mergeable CLEAN into release. - Local http://localhost:3004/up returned 200. - Focused PR-head tests passed with Ruby 3.3.11: bin/rails test test/models/session_mascot_test.rb test/controllers/api/v1/sessions_controller_test.rb test/lib/task_cli_test.rb test/commands/codex_session_title_test.rb (92 runs, 325 assertions).

Avi Heartbeat blocked review: carl: merge-ready - No blockers found. PR #276 satisfies the mascot allocation acceptance criteria, has green CI, passes local focused tests and DoR, and remains clean against release.; alex: request-changes - Light review found no code blocker, but DoR-to-merge currently refuses the task because recorded full-suite/rubocop evidence is stale for the current PR code.

Resolved QA blocker: rebased on current origin/release, verified local proof URL, reran focused tests plus full-suite/rubocop, force-pushed PR #276, and GitHub CI is green.

Scout report: merge-ready - Mascot allocation implementation satisfies backend acceptance: subagents draw from parent evolution trees, avoid sibling duplicates, and handle single/exhausted trees. Reporter: carl Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - none Questions: - none Checks: - DoR passes for backend with unit/integration plus full-suite/rubocop evidence at 95dc0d768b6a. - Migration adds parent_session_id with index; GitHub PR #276 CI is green and mergeState CLEAN.

Scout report: merge-ready - Documentation/session handoff behavior is covered; no remaining docs or CLI blocker after fresh DoR check. Reporter: alex Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - none Questions: - none Checks: - Local DoR passes on the current head, clearing the stale-evidence concern from the earlier dry-run report. - Task acceptance and tests cover branching, single-member, and exhausted evolution trees.