McRitchie Studio

Scout report: merge-ready - Light UI/data-cache read found no blockers; totals page renders week cards and Week 18 locally; CI green. PR remains draft. Reporter: shannon Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - No blocking UI, accessibility, or navigation defects found; mobile navbar fits at 320-390px and week selector scrolls horizontally as intended. - Merge-safety check found only app/views/admin/hub.html.erb overlap with feat/suite-consistency-cleanup in a different section; no overwrite risk for this PR. - Non-blocker: GitHub still marks PR #172 as draft, so Avi must account for ready-for-review state before merge handling. Questions: - none Checks: - Read AGENTS, pr-review-light SOP, Shannon role, and Turf Monster README/RUNBOOK/FORMULAS/UI_PATTERNS. - Reviewed task metadata, PR #172 body/files/CI via gh; CI green on 2590bfc, mergeable CLEAN, base release. - Local smoke: curl 200 for /nfl/team-totals and ?week=18; Playwright DOM probe saw Week 18 active with 16 cards and no new mobile nav overflow.

Scout report: wait-for-ci - Code, DOR, CI, acceptance, and merge safety are clean; PR #172 is still draft, so wait for ready-for-review state before Avi advances it. Reporter: carl Outcome: wait-for-ci Findings: - Gate: GitHub reports PR #172 isDraft=true; house qa-intake treats clean draft PRs as avi-ready-draft and not advanceable. Questions: - none Checks: - DOR green from Turf feature worktree: unit/component/integration/e2e tiers, full-suite+rubocop certified at c36b376895ea, GitHub CI 7/7 green. - Acceptance verified locally: cache rake reports 272 games and 544 team rows; /nfl/team-totals and week=18 return HTTP 200; DB has 18 weeks, 272 games, 544 projections, Week 18 has 16 game cards and 32 matchups with no missing expectations. - Merge safety: base release, mergeable MERGEABLE/CLEAN; only active overlap is PR169 admin hub in a different hunk and merge-tree has no conflict; PR170 has no overlap.

pr-review deferred team-totals-ui: wait-for-ci. carl: wait-for-ci - Code, DOR, CI, acceptance, and merge safety are clean; PR #172 is still draft, so wait for ready-for-review state before Avi advances it.; shannon: merge-ready - Light UI/data-cache read found no blockers; totals page renders week cards and Week 18 locally; CI green. PR remains draft.

Scout report: merge-ready - Primary review finds the NFL team totals UI and cache implementation matches acceptance; DoR, CI, focused Rails, Playwright, live URL, and data cache repeatability checks are green. Reporter: carl Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - No blockers. Weekly cards render expected totals, all weeks 1-18 are available, and the importer reruns idempotently against the baseline dataset. - Non-blocker: PR #172 is still marked draft on GitHub, but the task merge gate and code review are green. Questions: - none Checks: - DoR merge gate passed from Turf worktree: full suite and rubocop certified fresh at c36b376895ea; GitHub CI green with 7 checks. - Focused Rails tests passed: 9 runs, 40 assertions, 0 failures. - Playwright e2e/nfl_team_totals.spec.js passed against http://127.0.0.1:3103. - Data proof: nfl:expected_team_totals_cache YEAR=2026 cached 272 games, 544 team rows, 0 stale deleted.

Cleared review blocker: PR #172 is now ready for review, no longer draft. DOR remains green and GitHub CI is green on 2590bfc.

Scout report: merge-ready - Light UI/data-cache review found no blockers; PR matches weekly totals/navigation acceptance and CI is green. Reporter: shannon Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - No blockers. Non-blocking note: 320px local dev overflow is from existing development banner/header, not this totals UI. Questions: - none Checks: - Read AGENTS.md, Shannon role, pr-review-light SOP, turf-monster README/RUNBOOK/UI_PATTERNS/FORMULAS; inspected task metadata, PR body/status, diff, changed files/tests, local /nfl/team-totals DOM, and merge safety without rerunning gates.

Scout report: merge-ready - Primary review: acceptance, DOR, CI, and merge safety are green for PR #172. Reporter: carl Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - No blockers. NFL totals cache is transactional/idempotent for the 2026 baseline, uses existing game slug conventions, and the public totals page renders week data. - Non-blocker: open PR #169 also edits app/views/admin/hub.html.erb, but the hunks are separate and both PRs are clean against release. Questions: - none Checks: - DoR: /Users/alex/projects/mcritchie-studio/bin/dor-check team-totals-ui from the Turf worktree passed with tiers, full-suite/RuboCop cert, and CI green. - CI: gh pr checks 172 reports scan_ruby, scan_js, lint, test, and playwright (1-3) passing on 2590bfc. - Acceptance: localhost:3103 /up, /nfl/team-totals, and /nfl/team-totals?week=18 returned 200; CSV has weeks 1-18, 272 games, 544 team rows; Week 18 rendered 16 cards.

pr-review moved team-totals-ui to reviewed after carl + shannon reported merge-ready. Left for Steffon QA. Reports: - carl: merge-ready - Primary review: acceptance, DOR, CI, and merge safety are green for PR #172. - shannon: merge-ready - Light UI/data-cache review found no blockers; PR matches weekly totals/navigation acceptance and CI is green.

Resolved review feedback: PR #172 is ready for review, no longer draft; latest scout reports are merge-ready with no blockers; DOR and GitHub CI remain green on 2590bfc.