McRitchie Studio

Scout report: wait-for-ci - Code review is clean, but PR #370 is still draft / qa-intake avi-ready-draft; defer final Avi action until owner intent is confirmed and the PR is marked ready. Reporter: carl Outcome: wait-for-ci Findings: - Non-blocker: implementation meets acceptance in the reviewed diff; no code changes requested. - Workflow gate: PR #370 is draft even though GitHub CI is green and mergeability is clean; repo intake classifies avi-ready-draft as wait-for-ci/defer. - Non-blocker: open PR overlap is limited to db/schema.rb with #356/#371 and e2e/seed.rb with #371; this branch merge-tree is clean and #371 is already a separate needs-agent conflict. Questions: - none Checks: - Focused Rails suite green locally: 71 runs, 253 assertions, 0 failures. - bin/dor-check shiny-pokemon-mascot-avatars passed; GitHub CI lint/scan/test all pass on 4cde039. - Pokemon JSON has 151 rows, no missing shiny URLs, no duplicate dex/slug; sampled shiny S3 URLs for Bulbasaur/Pikachu/Mew returned 200 image/png. - git merge-tree --write-tree origin/release HEAD succeeded; http://localhost:3001/up returned 200.

Scout report: conductor-review - Code, CI, DoR, local focused checks, and S3 shiny assets are green; PR #370 is still draft/avi-ready-draft, so Avi should confirm owner intent and mark ready before stage advance. Reporter: shannon Outcome: conductor-review Findings: - No code blockers found: shiny odds, session/task shiny stamping, helper rendering, seed JSON, and rake URL generation match the acceptance criteria. - Procedural merge-safety: GitHub marks PR #370 draft while qa-intake classifies it avi-ready-draft; do not treat it as merge-ready until it is marked ready for review. - Open PR overlap checked: #371 also touches e2e/seed.rb, but its hunk is adjacent to this shiny fixture and #370 itself is GitHub merge-clean. Questions: - none Checks: - [unit+integration] PATH=/opt/homebrew/opt/ruby@3.3/bin... bin/rails test test/models/pokemon_shiny_test.rb test/models/session_mascot_shiny_test.rb test/models/task_mascot_shiny_test.rb test/integration/board_card_shiny_mascot_test.rb — 19 runs, 74 assertions, green - [component] PATH=/opt/homebrew/opt/ruby@3.3/bin... bin/rails test test/helpers/stage_agents_helper_test.rb — 52 runs, 179 assertions, green - [DoR] bin/dor-check shiny-pokemon-mascot-avatars — met; tiers green; full suite and rubocop certified at 3d0bc912f584 - [assets] HEAD-checked 453 shiny S3 artwork URLs from db/seeds/data/pokemon.json — bad=0 - [CI] gh pr checks 370 — lint, scan_js, scan_ruby, test all pass - [local] curl http://localhost:3001/up — 200

Avi Heartbeat deferred shiny-pokemon-mascot-avatars: wait-for-ci. shannon: conductor-review - Code, CI, DoR, local focused checks, and S3 shiny assets are green; PR #370 is still draft/avi-ready-draft, so Avi should confirm owner intent and mark ready before stage advance.; carl: wait-for-ci - Code review is clean, but PR #370 is still draft / qa-intake avi-ready-draft; defer final Avi action until owner intent is confirmed and the PR is marked ready.

Scout report: merge-ready - Light review found no code blockers: shiny reference data, draw odds, task/session stamping, and board avatar rendering match the acceptance criteria. Procedural note: PR #370 is still draft/avi-ready-draft, so mark ready before the final review/merge lane. Reporter: carl Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - blocker: none found in the code/data path. - non-blocker: PR #370 is draft while GitHub reports MERGEABLE and CI green; qa-intake labels it avi-ready-draft, so the primary/conductor should mark ready before final review/merge handling. - non-blocker: task post_deploy_cmd is bin/rails pokemon:seed, which is needed so existing QA/prod Pokemon rows receive the new shiny URL columns after migration. - merge-safety: current origin/release is ahead by 6 commits, but GitHub merge state is CLEAN/MERGEABLE and same-file overlap with release since merge-base is empty. Questions: - none Checks: - bin/rails test test/models/pokemon_shiny_test.rb test/models/session_mascot_shiny_test.rb test/models/task_mascot_shiny_test.rb test/integration/board_card_shiny_mascot_test.rb — 19 runs, 74 assertions, green (with Homebrew Ruby PATH). - bin/dor-check shiny-pokemon-mascot-avatars — DoR-to-Merge met; unit/component/integration/e2e plus full-suite and rubocop recorded green. - GitHub checks on PR #370 — lint, scan_js, scan_ruby, test all SUCCESS; gh reports mergeable MERGEABLE and draft true. - Reference-data audit — db/seeds/data/pokemon.json has 151 rows, no missing shiny fields, 453 unique shiny URLs; sampled S3 shiny assets returned HTTP 200. - Local proof — http://localhost:3001/up and /tasks returned HTTP 200; worktree clean.

Scout report: conductor-review - No code or acceptance blockers found, but PR #370 is still draft/avi-ready-draft; Avi should confirm owner intent and mark ready before final stage advance. Reporter: shannon Outcome: conductor-review Findings: - [blocker/procedural] PR #370 is draft while mergeStateStatus is CLEAN; qa-intake classifies it avi-ready-draft, so the remaining issue is owner/conductor readiness, not implementation. - [non-blocker] Shiny implementation matches acceptance: all 151 JSON rows have shiny URL triples, draw odds are 1-in-100 prod and 1-in-10 dev/QA, shiny state persists on SessionMascot/Task, and board avatars render shiny sprites. - [non-blocker] Merge safety: current PR is clean against release; note open PR #371 overlaps db/schema.rb and e2e/seed.rb but is already DIRTY/needs-agent, so release ordering should watch that conflict. Questions: - none Checks: - Read AGENTS.md, README.md, RUNBOOK.md, ECOSYSTEM.md, PR review/Avi heartbeat/task-board/testing docs, task metadata, PR body, changed files, and CI state. - GitHub CI for head 4cde039a is green: scan_ruby, scan_js, lint, test all pass; gh reports mergeable/CLEAN but draft=true. - bin/dor-check shiny-pokemon-mascot-avatars passed; targeted Rails tests passed: 71 runs, 253 assertions, 0 failures. - Verified reference and S3 assets: 151 Pokemon rows, 453 shiny URLs checked, 0 failures; /up on localhost:3001 returned 200. - E2E rerun passed with Ruby 3.3: E2E_PORT=3099 npx playwright test e2e/shiny_mascot.spec.js (1 passed).

Avi Heartbeat deferred shiny-pokemon-mascot-avatars: conductor-review. shannon: conductor-review - No code or acceptance blockers found, but PR #370 is still draft/avi-ready-draft; Avi should confirm owner intent and mark ready before final stage advance.; carl: merge-ready - Light review found no code blockers: shiny reference data, draw odds, task/session stamping, and board avatar rendering match the acceptance criteria. Procedural note: PR #370 is still draft/avi-ready-draft, so mark ready before the final review/merge lane.

Scout report: request-changes - Light review found the shiny mascot implementation and data coverage sound, but PR #370 is not merge-safe until the draft/conflict/migration-lane issues are corrected. Reporter: carl Outcome: request-changes Findings: - Blocker: PR #370 is still draft and GitHub reports mergeable=CONFLICTING against release; local merge-tree reproduces a db/schema.rb conflict. - Blocker: task metadata has requires_migration=false even though the PR adds two migrations and changes db/schema.rb; backend_migration lane policy requires the flag. - Non-blocker: code/data review matched acceptance criteria; 151 Pokemon rows carry 453 shiny URLs and focused Rails checks passed after resetting the test DB. Questions: - none Checks: - CI: gh pr checks 370 reported lint, scan_js, scan_ruby, and test all passing. - Local: RAILS_ENV=test bin/rails db:test:purge db:test:prepare, then bin/rails test test/models/pokemon_shiny_test.rb test/models/session_mascot_shiny_test.rb test/models/task_mascot_shiny_test.rb test/helpers/stage_agents_helper_test.rb test/integration/board_card_shiny_mascot_test.rb passed: 71 runs, 253 assertions. - Data: git-show JSON validation found rows=151, missing shiny fields=0, shiny_urls=453, bad_patterns=0. - Merge safety: git merge-tree origin/release with origin/feat/shiny-pokemon-mascot-avatars shows db/schema.rb changed in both with conflict markers.

Scout report: request-changes - Implementation matches the shiny mascot acceptance criteria and checks are green, but PR #370 is draft and not mergeable: current origin/release conflicts in db/schema.rb, so the branch needs a rebase/schema regeneration before Avi can advance it. Reporter: shannon Outcome: request-changes Findings: - [blocker] Merge safety failed: GitHub reports mergeStateStatus=DIRTY/mergeable=CONFLICTING and git merge-tree --write-tree origin/release HEAD reports CONFLICT (content) in db/schema.rb. - [blocker] PR #370 is still draft, so it is not ready for the review-to-merge lane until the owner/builder marks it ready. - [non-blocker] Code and data match acceptance: 151 unique Pokemon seed rows all include shiny_avatar_url, shiny_avatar_fallback_url, and shiny_sprite_url; all 453 committed shiny S3 URLs returned 2xx; shiny odds are prod 1-in-100 and dev/QA 1-in-10; task/session metadata renders shiny board avatars. - [merge-risk] Open PR #371 overlaps db/schema.rb and e2e/seed.rb; current release already causes the db/schema.rb conflict, and #371 landing first would require another rebase/seed merge check. Questions: - none Checks: - Read AGENTS.md, README.md, RUNBOOK.md, docs/ECOSYSTEM.md, Avi HEARTBEAT/pr-review SOP, shared pr-review primitive, devops task-board docs, data model/deployment docs, and culture doc. - Reviewed task metadata, PR body, changed files, migrations, models, helpers, seed JSON, rake tasks, docs, tests, GitHub CI, PR comments/reviews, and open-PR overlap. - Local verification after resetting the feature worktree test DB: bin/rails test test/models/pokemon_shiny_test.rb test/models/session_mascot_shiny_test.rb test/models/task_mascot_shiny_test.rb; bin/rails test test/helpers/stage_agents_helper_test.rb; bin/rails test test/integration/board_card_shiny_mascot_test.rb; combined targeted command 71 runs/253 assertions green. - bin/dor-check shiny-pokemon-mascot-avatars passed; gh pr checks #370 reports scan_ruby, scan_js, lint, and test passing; git diff --check clean; S3 HEAD check covered 453 shiny URLs with bad=0.

Avi Heartbeat blocked review: shannon: request-changes - Implementation matches the shiny mascot acceptance criteria and checks are green, but PR #370 is draft and not mergeable: current origin/release conflicts in db/schema.rb, so the branch needs a rebase/schema regeneration before Avi can advance it.; carl: request-changes - Light review found the shiny mascot implementation and data coverage sound, but PR #370 is not merge-safe until the draft/conflict/migration-lane issues are corrected.

Rework addressed: rebased onto current origin/release (18 commits), schema.rb regenerated via db:migrate at version 20260704090100 carrying both sides, PR #370 marked ready (draft cleared) and now MERGEABLE. Full suite + rubocop re-certified green at 420eea74cf87; CI re-running on the rebased head.

Scout report: merge-ready - Primary review found PR 370 meets shiny mascot acceptance; CI and fresh targeted checks are green; merge-ready for Avi. Reporter: shannon Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - No blockers. Reference data contains 151 unique Pokemon rows with shiny avatar, fallback, and sprite URLs; task declares post_deploy_cmd=bin/rails pokemon:seed for deployed data refresh. - Non-blocking overlap with PR 371 on db/schema.rb and e2e/seed.rb; git merge-tree --write-tree with feat/release-stage-timestamp-handoff produced a clean merged tree. Questions: - none Checks: - GitHub PR 370: open, non-draft, base release, mergeStateStatus CLEAN, CI scan_ruby/scan_js/lint/test all SUCCESS on 4716343b. - bin/rails test test/models/pokemon_shiny_test.rb test/models/session_mascot_shiny_test.rb test/models/task_mascot_shiny_test.rb test/helpers/stage_agents_helper_test.rb test/integration/board_card_shiny_mascot_test.rb — 71 runs, 253 assertions, green. - npx playwright test e2e/shiny_mascot.spec.js — 1 passed. - bin/dor-check shiny-pokemon-mascot-avatars — DoR-to-Merge met; tiers green; full suite and rubocop certified. - db/seeds/data/pokemon.json audit — 151 rows, 151 unique dex, 151 unique slugs, all 151 have shiny_avatar_url/shiny_avatar_fallback_url/shiny_sprite_url; representative S3 HEADs returned 200 image/png.

Scout report: merge-ready - Light review found the shiny mascot PR meets acceptance; DoR, CI, focused tests, local smoke, and S3 asset checks are green. Reporter: carl Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - No blockers: task metadata declares post_deploy_cmd=bin/rails pokemon:seed, committed JSON has 151 Pokemon with all shiny URL fields, and all 453 shiny S3 URLs returned image/*. - Non-blocker: PR #371 also touches db/schema.rb and e2e/seed.rb; overlap is additive, GitHub reports PR #370 MERGEABLE/CLEAN, and merge-tree showed no conflict markers. Questions: - none Checks: - [dor] bin/dor-check shiny-pokemon-mascot-avatars — ready to advance submitted to reviewed. - [unit+component+integration] RAILS_ENV=test bin/rails db:test:purge db:test:prepare; bin/rails test test/models/pokemon_shiny_test.rb test/models/session_mascot_shiny_test.rb test/models/task_mascot_shiny_test.rb test/helpers/stage_agents_helper_test.rb test/integration/board_card_shiny_mascot_test.rb — 71 runs, 253 assertions, green. - [ci] gh pr checks 370 — scan_ruby, scan_js, lint, test all pass on current PR run. - [s3-assets] Ruby HEAD check over shiny_avatar_url, shiny_avatar_fallback_url, shiny_sprite_url for all 151 rows — checked 453 URLs, all reachable image/*. - [smoke] curl http://localhost:3001/up — 200.

Avi Heartbeat moved shiny-pokemon-mascot-avatars to reviewed after shannon + carl reported merge-ready. Left for Steffon QA. Reports: - shannon: merge-ready - Primary review found PR 370 meets shiny mascot acceptance; CI and fresh targeted checks are green; merge-ready for Avi. - carl: merge-ready - Light review found the shiny mascot PR meets acceptance; DoR, CI, focused tests, local smoke, and S3 asset checks are green.