McRitchie Studio

Scout report: request-changes - Request changes: unresolved feedback state is not wired into the DevOps decision path, and merge sequencing conflicts with PR #282 remain. Reporter: shannon Outcome: request-changes Findings: - Blocker: bin/devops-cycle still returns request-changes only when latest_activity.activity_type == qa_feedback (bin/devops-cycle:524), so qa_feedback followed by a non-resolving handoff/comment can be misclassified despite Task.unresolved_feedback_by_slug existing. - Merge safety: PR #292 is clean against origin/release, but pairwise merge-tree with PR #282 conflicts in app/models/activity.rb, app/views/tasks/show.html.erb, and bin/task; this follow-up should be rebased or sequenced after review-comment-taxonomy. - Non-blocker: PR #292 is still draft; qa-intake reports avi-ready-draft and GitHub mergeable=MERGEABLE with green checks. Questions: - none Checks: - Reviewed AGENTS.md, README, RUNBOOK, ECOSYSTEM, DevOps/task-board/testing docs. - Reviewed PR #292 body, changed files, task metadata, CI, local /up, and git merge-tree against origin/release. - Ran focused Rails tests: 195 runs, 1015 assertions, 0 failures.

Scout report: request-changes - Request changes: focused implementation checks pass, but the task fails DoR and PR #292 conflicts with active prerequisite PR #282 before it can be merge-ready. Reporter: carl Outcome: request-changes Findings: - Blocker: bin/dor-check feedback-resolution-state fails because checks_run only records CI; it is missing unit/component/integration/e2e tags and fingerprint-bound full-suite/rubocop evidence for PR head d64965e. - Blocker: pairwise merge-tree with active PR #282 conflicts in app/models/activity.rb, app/views/tasks/show.html.erb, and bin/task; #292 should be rebased/stacked after the clarification taxonomy work or explicitly sequenced by Avi. - Non-blocker: unresolved_feedback replay semantics, explicit resolving handoff metadata, task-card/detail badges, API show fields, and bin/task note --resolves-feedback match the requested behavior in focused review. - Question: none. Questions: - none Checks: - Read AGENTS.md, qa-release SOP, repo README/RUNBOOK/ECOSYSTEM, task-board scout docs, task metadata, PR body, diff, changed files, tests, CI, qa-intake, and merge safety. - GitHub PR #292 targets release, is draft/avi-ready-draft, is mergeable/CLEAN against current release, and lint, test, scan_js, and scan_ruby all pass. - Local focused suite passed in .worktrees/feedback-resolution-state: mise exec ruby@3.3.11 -- bin/rails test test/models/activity_test.rb test/models/task_intent_test.rb test/controllers/api/v1/tasks_controller_test.rb test/controllers/tasks_controller_test.rb test/lib/task_cli_test.rb test/system/review_followup_guard_test.rb (178 runs, 771 assertions). - Local smoke: http://localhost:3022/up returned 200; task detail URL redirects to /tasks in the local DB.

Avi Heartbeat blocked review: shannon: request-changes - Request changes: unresolved feedback state is not wired into the DevOps decision path, and merge sequencing conflicts with PR #282 remain.; carl: request-changes - Request changes: focused implementation checks pass, but the task fails DoR and PR #292 conflicts with active prerequisite PR #282 before it can be merge-ready.

Resolved code/DoR blockers: rebased on current origin/release, wired unresolved QA feedback into bin/devops-cycle conductor decisions, added regression coverage for a later handoff masking QA feedback, reran focused tests plus full-suite/rubocop, force-pushed PR #292, and GitHub CI is green. PR #292 remains draft intentionally so it can sequence after PR #282.

Scout report: merge-ready - UI/task card unresolved feedback state now composes cleanly with the clarification taxonomy from PR #282. Reporter: shannon Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - none Questions: - none Checks: - Focused rebased suite passed: 206 runs, 1089 assertions, 0 failures. - GitHub PR #292 is non-draft, mergeState CLEAN, and CI lint/scan/test are green on head 99f28ef.

Scout report: merge-ready - Backend feedback resolution logic is explicit via handoff metadata and devops-cycle unresolved feedback checks; rebase conflict with #282 is resolved. Reporter: carl Outcome: merge-ready Findings: - none Questions: - none Checks: - Full-suite gate passed at ccad5e777d70 with 2118 runs, 10020 assertions, 0 failures; RuboCop clean across 583 files. - DoR passes for ui+db after rebase onto release.

Resolved: unresolved-feedback state IS wired into the DevOps decision path — bin/devops-cycle returns request-changes when task.unresolved_feedback is present (bin/devops-cycle:550-552), derived from qa_feedback minus resolving handoffs. Regression: 'conductor decisions preserve unresolved feedback after later handoff' (devops_cycle_command_test.rb:283). PR #282 merge-sequencing conflict moot post-merge. Green on main.